Take the 2-minute tour ×
English Language Learners Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for speakers of other languages learning English. It's 100% free, no registration required.

Sorry I lost the context of the phrase, but as far as I remember when I looked up the phrase on Google I felt it didn't matter. I felt it had one meaning. At any rate, could you tell me whatever meaning you know, or where I could look into it.

The phrase is: "take the points raised". Is it an idiom?

P.S: I've just found the post. Two guys discussing a grammar question. Now one of them wrote the following as a reply quoting from the other guy:

So - and please help me understand this - to take the points raised: "...not impossible, in my opinion, but 'Have you ever been there?' is more natural in the situations I can think of"

Why? I tried to explain why it was both 'natural', and correct grammar in terms of the sentence provided.

share|improve this question
    
Does that mean, I take the points back. Points mean objections?! It looks different after I posted the question up. –  learner Dec 19 '13 at 16:23
1  
No. It means to understand the points that were raised. –  Damkerng T. Dec 19 '13 at 16:24
add comment

4 Answers

up vote 5 down vote accepted

When you "raise a point", you are bringing up an issue to be discussed. After someone has raised a point, you can refer to it as "the point [that has been] raised."

One possible sense of take is consider, as in "take, for example, the lowly worm." (You are not being asked to physically acquire a worm, but to think about some aspect of it.)

Thus, when you want others to examine the issue that someone brought up, you can ask them to "take the point raised".

share|improve this answer
add comment

The quote is not the idiomatic "I take your point"; it's a more literal use of points as in "objectives" or "questions", and take as in "consider".

point n.
15. An objective or purpose to be reached or achieved, or one that is worth reaching or achieving: What is the point of discussing this issue further?
16. The major idea or essential part of a concept or narrative: You have missed the whole point of the novel.
17. A significant, outstanding, or effective idea, argument, or suggestion: Your point is well taken.

take v.tr.
25.b. To consider; assume: Take the matter as settled.

This sense of take is often used with "Let's".

Let's take the first question you asked.
Let's take your points one by one.

Thus, your "to take the points raised" can be rephrased as "to consider the issues that have been brought up".

share|improve this answer
    
It's quite strange that in this very specific context, I understand it as "to see", not "to consider". I don't know if you would agree with me. –  Damkerng T. Dec 19 '13 at 17:08
    
@DamkerngT.: (pardon me, this is getting into serious use-mention confusion land) I don't see how "to see" could make any sense in this context. –  Martha Dec 19 '13 at 17:11
add comment

The verb "to take" has various meanings, in addition to "to physically seize and remove something".

About conversation, it can mean:

  • to accept or withstand something which is said in some way. "take a compliment"; "take an insult"; "take an order"

  • to agree, concede or acquiesce: "I take your point." "Point taken." "I can take a hint."

  • to understand or interpret a statement or situation. "So, I take it that you're quitting?"

  • to consider something. "take into account"; "take into consideration"; "take the points raised"

These meanings overlap. To consider something, we understand and interpret it, and also we perhaps accept it to some degree.

In this case the writer probably means something like:

In consideration and acceptance of the points raised, let me reiterate my revised idea so you can check whether I have the proper understanding.

share|improve this answer
    
+1, though I understand the quote to be saying, "I will address the ideas that you have mentioned as follows." –  Wayne Feb 14 at 1:42
add comment

Update:

Please note that the expression to raise my point(s) is quite common in conversation. It means that the speaker has just brought "his or her point(s)" up into the discussion. The term "raised point(s)" refers to some ideas or arguments that were put forward by someone in the discussion.

Once someone has raised his or her points, anyone might invite everyone in the discussion to consider the points that were just made, in order to discuss the raised points in further details. One common expression among others is to take the points raised, which means to consider that already mentioned points. For further details on this typical usage, you can read Martha's and Hellion's answers.

My confusion was caused by unfamiliar punctuation (and quite likely, my non-native'ness) which convinced me to interpret that specific line in an unusual way (unusual both for anyone and myself, actually). In case you might be curious, you could read the details in the comments below. (If all you want is the answer to your original question, you don't really need doing so.)

Also note that the word take can mean several things. (Most seemingly simple words are like that. They seem to be easy, but actually, they can convey a wide range of different subtle senses. Quite often, they will convey multiple senses at the same time.) You can read Kaz's answer for more details on take.

The following is my original answer, based on the (mis)understanding that take the points in the question should be interpreted idiomatically. I leave it here because it is a useful piece of information by and in itself.


The phrase take someone's point is idiomatic.

From Wiktionary,

take someone's point
verb
1. (idiomatic) To agree with what a person says; to understand a person's argument and be persuaded by it.
2. (idiomatic) To grasp the essential meaning of what a person is saying.  

Synonyms
- (grasp the essential meaning): get someone's point, see someone's point, take someone's meaning

share|improve this answer
    
Perfect! & thanks. –  learner Dec 19 '13 at 16:26
1  
Good information, but in the context given I can't agree that this is the actual use or the intended meaning; the surroundings clearly indicate that the person doesn't understand what's being said. –  Hellion Dec 19 '13 at 16:48
    
@Hellion I think it (take the points) can be either used literally (let's consider these points) or idiomatically (to get someone's points). I believe that it will depend on the intention of the speaker. If he wanted to say let's take the points raised, then it would be the literal usage. But if I understand the guy correctly, he asked for helps so he can understand the points. –  Damkerng T. Dec 19 '13 at 16:52
    
I agree, he's asking for help to understand. That's why I say that the meaning you've given cannot be valid; your meaning is saying "I (already) understand and agree", not "I need help to understand". –  Hellion Dec 19 '13 at 16:57
1  
@DamkerngT., I don't know what "to see the points raised" would mean there, so I don't think it's a valid rephrasing. –  Hellion Dec 19 '13 at 20:04
show 4 more comments

Your Answer

 
discard

By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.