Take the 2-minute tour ×
English Language Learners Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for speakers of other languages learning English. It's 100% free, no registration required.

A question from my student:

I'm rather confused how many syllables in the words with suffix -ian? Some words like 'e-lec-tri-cian, mu-si-cian, A-sian' have only one syllable while ' veg-e-tar-i-an, co-me-di-an, his-to-ri-an' have two. Is there any rule for this or just memorize them?

In her examples, the first set is stressed on the second-to-last syllable, the second set on the third-to-last. But how can we know the difference?

share|improve this question
    
Perhaps they need to look the words up in dictionaries. One pattern I can observe (while reading this question) is that the last syllable seems to always be either /shən/ or /zhən/ in your first group. –  Damkerng T. Feb 12 at 16:22
add comment

2 Answers 2

up vote 7 down vote accepted

I would say a good rule of thumb is to look at the base form of the word.

If the base form of the word ends in a "y," then a noun form ending in "-ian" will generally be pronounced as two syllables. Intuitively, these words have a hard time losing that "ee" sound. For example:

  • comedy => comedian
  • custody => custodian
  • history => historian
  • library => librarian
  • ovary => ovarian

If the base form of the word ends in a "c" or "g" (velar stops), then that originally hard "k" or "g" sound becomes "sh" or "j" respectively in front of the front vowel "i" of "-ian" and is pronounced as a single syllable (a form of elision). A similar transformation can happen for words that already end in "s" or "sh" sounds. For example:

  • clinic => clinician
  • cosmetic => cosmetician
  • magic => magician
  • theology => theologian
  • Venice => Venetian

If the base form ends in most other consonants or vowels other than "y", then the "-ian" ending cannot be elided with the final consonant/vowel into a single syllable, and thus is pronounced as two syllables. In the case of final vowels, an infix "-n-" is generally used to separate the final vowel from the "-ian" ending. For example:

  • guard => guardian
  • pluto => plutonian

Finally, examples like "Asian" are in fact a slightly different construct, wherein the suffix "-n" is used to make an adjective. Words that would be confusing in this regard because they end in "-ian" include:

  • Asia => Asian [one-syllable "-ian"]
  • mammal => mammalian [two-syllable "-ian"] (here the root is really the Latin "mammalia" which is the term used for the Class of mammals)
share|improve this answer
    
good answer but theology -> theologian goes in the first set as it ends in y –  nathan hayfield Feb 13 at 1:04
    
I should have elaborated. "Theology" represents an exception to the "-y" rule of thumb, but belongs in this second group of examples because the "-ian" suffix is pronounced as one syllable. –  semperos Feb 13 at 2:26
    
that is incorrect, theologian is pronounced with with two syllables. –  nathan hayfield Feb 13 at 16:26
    
That is not correct. Theologian is pronounced /θiəˈloʊdʒən/, syllables broken down to the-o-lo-gian. As a native speaker I can confirm this, and you can refer to the Wiktionary entry for theologian as confirmation. –  semperos Feb 13 at 16:37
    
as a fellow native speaker, i have to disagree with both you and your wiki –  nathan hayfield Feb 13 at 18:12
show 3 more comments

A rather reliable rule of thumb is as follows, although there are always exceptions.

The letters -(i)an in these endings are pronounced as -/ən/, so as one syllable:

-sian
-cian
-tian
-gian

So it depends on the letter that comes before -ian. Other -ian endings are pronounced as -/ɪən/ (two syllables) or -/jən/: the difference between these two pronunciations is often hard to hear.

Another way to put it is as follows. If the sound of the preceding consonant changes because of the -i-, that means -ian should be pronounced in a way where you can't hear -i- as a separate sound. So if -s- is pronounced as /ʒ/ rather than /s/ or /z/, -sian is pronounced as -/ʒən/. The same applies if -c- is pronounced as /ʃ/ rather than /s/ (→ -/ʃən/), or if -t- is pronounced as /ʃ/ rather than /t/ (→ -/ʃən/). This does not apply to -g-, though.

The same rule usually applies to -ion, -ial, -ious, and similar suffixes with -i-[vowel]-, mutatis mutandis.


Legend for the International Phonetic Alphabet:

  • ʃ = sh as in English sheep
  • ʒ = j as in French jeu, and -si- as in English Asian
  • ə = a as in English an, and e as in the (the sound is called schwa)
share|improve this answer
    
So the difference is really between words where the elision of –i- is optional (like historian) and those where it’s required (like magician). The learner would need to focus on how the final consonant in the base changes – being unsure about this means he or she will likely fall back on the reading pronounciation (–ian as two syllables). Thanks! –  neubau Feb 16 at 12:46
add comment

Your Answer

 
discard

By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.