Take the 2-minute tour ×
English Language Learners Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for speakers of other languages learning English. It's 100% free, no registration required.

I can use Who are you ? When talking to one person.

However, what can I use if I'm talking to a group of people ?

share|improve this question
    
The plural of “person” is usually “people”. –  Tyler James Young Apr 15 at 18:27
    
So should I say: ...talking to people, instead of ...talking to a group of persons ? –  elhoucine Apr 15 at 21:07
    
Yes, either “talking to people” or “talking to a group of people” is the way to say it. “Persons” is obsolete. –  Tyler James Young Apr 15 at 21:09
    
Updated. Thank you. –  elhoucine Apr 15 at 21:11
    
There is only one WHO, so why would you need a plural? –  CodesInChaos Apr 16 at 9:16

3 Answers 3

up vote 9 down vote accepted

“Who” can be made plural the usual way, but that is not what is needed here

The “Whos” And “Wheres” Of iOS Device Usage Explained
Source: TechCrunch headline

This is a plural in the sense that it refers to multiple mentions of (or answers to) the question “who?”.


“Who” does not have a plural form like the way that “is” changes to “are”
Generally speaking, the word “who” is a pronoun. It stands in for the mention of a person or people, but has no power to determine in and of itself how many people the speaker is talking about.


“You” does not have a plural form either, but can refer to multiple people
The word “you” in your sentence does not have to change in order to refer to multiple people. To make the reference more clear, you can add “two” or “all” as in “you two” or “you all” (or, regionally, “y'all”).


If you want to ask about the identity of multiple people, convey this with other words

  1. “all” after “who”
    Person A: We will need four more chairs set at the dinner table tonight.
    Person B: Who all will be joining us?
    This construction is informal and mainly AmE.

    “all” after “you”
    Group A: Trick or treat!
    Person B: Who are you all supposed to be?
    As indicated above, the contraction “y'all” is employed this way in some regions.
  2. “people”
    Group A: Surprise! You win this prize for being the 100th person to cross this new bridge!
    Person B: Who are you people?
    This construction may be considered brusque.
  3. “they”
    Person A: You've never heard of the Kardashians?
    Person B: No, who are they?
    “They” is usually third person plural but can also be third person singular.
share|improve this answer
    
Note: in Early Modern English, "You" was plural, with "Thou" being singular. On top of that, "You" functioned as singular but respectful (similar to Majestic Plural, "We, the King of...", king talking of self in plural.) Over time the polite, respectful form simply pushed 'Thou' out of use and current English has only the plural, and plural-as-singular form 'You'. –  SF. Apr 15 at 19:10
    
@SF. I had to restrain myself from discussing the fascinating history of pronouns and plurals in English, back through thees and thous and on to Old English's ability to convey pluralness with adjectives, nouns, and most verbs. Thank you for the note—it makes me feel better about having had that inclination. –  Tyler James Young Apr 15 at 19:35
    
Great answer, however, the using of "all" and "people" in the examples 1 and 2 is optional or mandatory ? –  elhoucine Apr 15 at 21:24
    
Optional. Most of the time you can just rely on context to make your meaning clear. These constructions are just for emphasis or being extra clear. They aren't uncommon, because it can sometimes be difficult to convey that you want to know who everyone is (another option) unless you can gesture or sweep your eyes across all of them. –  Tyler James Young Apr 15 at 21:38
    
Tyler, thank you very much. –  elhoucine Apr 15 at 22:09

It is the same in the plural:

Who is your best friend?
Who are your best friends?

 

Who are you? (to one person)
Who are you? (to more than one person) or
Who are you all?

share|improve this answer

There is at least one other common possibility that I do not see listed:

Who are all of you?

with "all of you" being synonymous with "you all."

Another example: Where are all of you going to eat?

share|improve this answer

Your Answer

 
discard

By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.