Take the 2-minute tour ×
English Language Learners Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for speakers of other languages learning English. It's 100% free, no registration required.

If there is a name of a band, like The Black Keys, do you say "The Black Keys are awesome*" or "The Black Keys is awesome"?

Normally, you would say a band is 'they,' but then you would say 'they are awesome', but a band is one thing so you would say 'that band is awesome.' Which one is correct for a name like The Black Keys?

Any help would be appreciated

share|improve this question
add comment

2 Answers 2

up vote 4 down vote accepted

Band is a collective noun, and so is The Black Keys. In British English you can use either is or are (also, was or were), depending on how you view the noun. Plural verbs are more common overall.

If a collective noun is seen as a whole, sole, impersonal unit, then singular verbs are more common:

If your band isn't this week's priority, you are probably going to be forgotten.

The band is made up of two men.

(From British National Corpus)

If it is seen as a collection of people doing personal things, then plural verbs are more common:

Meanwhile, the band are currently working on a third album to follow '91's ‘The Beast Inside’.

Meanwhile, the band are currently writing songs for a new studio LP which will feature a host of guest vocalists — many of whom have been affiliated with The Pogues during their nine-year history.

‘This was about the time The Beatles were just starting and they were considered to have long hair, [...]

The Rolling Stones are fined £5 each for urinating in a garage forecourt after a concert in Romford, Essex.

(From British National Corpus)

Liverpool are winning.

(From Collins COBUILD English Usage)

This affects the use of relative pronouns, too. When you see a collective noun as an impersonal unit, which is preferred, whereas if you see it as a collection of people, who is preferred.

The committee, who are hoping to announce important changes, ...

The committee, which is elected at the annual meeting, ...

(from Practical English Usage, entry 526)

In American English the verb for the noun is usually singular in all cases except family (if you don't quantify it with members of, people in etc). However, plural pronouns with plural verbs can be used, so it is possible to find that one uses the band is and then refers back to the band as they (rather than it).

"What's your name? " I ask her, as the other mothers pull their kids away, too, because a Jesus band is singing on the main stage and there's soon to be a raffle for a homemade quilt and a free rototilling.

"My family are probably the oldest Shia family in Lebanon," she explains

(From COCA)

Source: Collins COBUILD English Usage and Practical English Usage

share|improve this answer
    
Speaking as a native speaker of American English, I do not think there is an exception for "family" in this case. The example sentence seems foreign or wrong. "My family is probably the oldest Shia family in Lebanon" would be the unmarked American English way to say it. –  nohat Jun 10 at 16:39
add comment

In your example:

The Black Keys is/are awesome.

you are probably talking about the members of the band, so you should use are. But if you say:

The Black Keys band is awesome.

then you would use is.

On the other hand,

The members of the Black Keys are awesome.

The band is singular, and the members in the band are plural.

share|improve this answer
2  
A useless answer - the question is not 'What is a plural?' –  jwg Jun 6 at 9:57
add comment

Your Answer

 
discard

By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.