Take the 2-minute tour ×
English Language Learners Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for speakers of other languages learning English. It's 100% free, no registration required.

"Is it left-handed?" OR "Is it for left-handed?"

Which one is correct way to ask whether something is specially made for left-handed?

My homework:

A left-handed guitar

is a valid sentence and this assures me that my way of asking is proper.

I bought a guitar for you. ~ Thanks, but is it left-handed?

Somehow, to me, this way of asking seems better. Because left-handed is an adjective which in this context better take preposition for:

I bought a guitar for you. ~ Thanks, but is it for left-handed (like me, which is understood)?

share|improve this question
1  
If you want a noun, and think a left-handed person is a bit too long, there is another word, left-hander. –  Damkerng T. Aug 22 at 8:22

2 Answers 2

The proper way to say it would be "Is it left-handed?"

If you say "is it FOR left-handed" then the question is, left-handed what? The thing that 'left-handed' is describing in the first example is "it" (the object you are asking about). In the second example, however, "Is it for left-handed", the thing being described as left-handed is missing, making the sentence sound incomplete and awkward. The object being described could be completed as "Is it for left handed writing/playing/people/children/drumming/etc." To make it correct you would have to include what is left-handed.

share|improve this answer
2  
It may be interesting to note that this is a case of a transferred epithet: strictly speaking, it is not the guitar that is left-handed, but the person that will use it. It is very common and readily understood, but it may be confusing when you think of it too much. :) –  oerkelens Aug 22 at 8:29
    
How would you form a question out of It is a left-handed guitar? With an answer yes/no. –  Maulik V Aug 22 at 8:48
    
I would say, "Is it a left-handed guitar?" or the slightly modified "Is the guitar for left-handed people?" –  Peramia Aug 22 at 8:51
    
This answer nails it. "I bought you some new golf clubs." "Thanks, but are they left-handed?" Sure, you can add the word clubs after left-handed, but it's quite unnecessary in informal conversation. Another informal way you could refer to the person instead of the clubs would be, "Thanks, but are they for lefties?" –  J.R. Aug 22 at 9:01
1  
You could also ask "is it for the left-handed?" Note the the in there. That (at least to me) puts more than normal emphasis on the question, though. That also allows some more variation (usable by the left-handed, useful for the left-handed, etc.) Is it left-handed? is definitely the normal way to ask this. –  derobert Aug 22 at 10:31

It's perfectly reasonable to describe an object designed to be used by left-handed people as itself being "left-handed". But, as discussed in Peramia's answer, "Is it for left-handed?" is an incomplete sentence because "left-handed" is an adjective. You could either say "Is it for left-handed people?" or "Is it for left-handers?"

"Is it for lefties" is rather informal and I probably wouldn't use it myself. I don't think it's at all offensive but it seems to be more common for left-handed people to use it to talk about themselves, and I'm a "righty". I would also avoid "Is it for the left-handed?" as, while grammatically correct, it feels rather laboured. Also, for example, disabled people tend to dislike being referred to as "the disabled" and "the left-handed" is the same kind of thing, though, again, rather less likely to cause any real offense.

share|improve this answer
    
In the context of 'a beautiful flower', I may tell someone - I've bought a flower for you. ~ Is it beautiful?; Yes, it is. Just like you!. Beautiful is an adjective but still used that way. –  Maulik V Aug 22 at 11:49
2  
@MaulikV I don't understand your point. The question "Is it beautiful?" makes perfect sense: the adjective "beautiful" is applied to the pronoun "it". Likewise, in "Is it left-handed?", the adjective "left-handed" is being applied to the pronoun "it". But in "Is it for left-handed?", the adjective "left-handed" is not being applied to the pronoun "it". –  David Richerby Aug 22 at 12:00
    
mea culpa. I read it without for. However, I remember that some words don't take any article (especially physically challenged people--say--deaf). "Is it for deaf" is okay. However, it serves as a noun but somehow I am getting confused with left-handed. –  Maulik V Aug 22 at 12:05
    
@MaulikV No, "Is it for deaf?" is not OK, for exactly the same reason that "Is it for left-handed?" is not OK. "Deaf" is an adjective. It can serve as a noun with the article ("the deaf") but, like disabled people, deaf people prefer to be called "deaf people" than "the deaf" –  David Richerby Aug 22 at 12:14
    
I had read a headline somewhere... "something for deaf". Not getting the link though I tried just now. –  Maulik V Aug 22 at 12:32

Your Answer

 
discard

By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.