0

I don't understand why second being is progressive.

He went from being a poor student to being an outstanding one.

1
  • Can you explain the grammar rule that you think makes the second "being" wrong?
    – Andrew
    Jan 12, 2018 at 0:59

2 Answers 2

1

I think you may be confusing the preposition "to" used here with the difference between gerunds (verb plus "-ing") and infinitives (to + verb).

sentence with a gerund: I enjoy swimming. (Gerunds do not use "to".)

sentence with an infinitive: I want to swim.

In your sentence, "to being" does not act as a gerund or an infinitive. The preposition "to" connects the first idea (that the student was poor) to the second (that the student became an outstanding one).

1

Because “it” here in this context doesn’t act like the same you are considering in your mind.

This kind of “to” isn’t infinitive (to + verb1)

Here “it” illustrates moving from place to place (from condition to another) (from being a poor student to being an outstanding one)

This Link explains that there are a few cases where you use to + V + -ing:

1) If the to is part of a phrasal verb or verb + preposition combination: A phrasal verb is something like "look forward to", "confess to", etc. In this case, the "to" is part of the verb itself. Some examples are:

  • I am looking forward to attending the party
  • I am committed to supporting the Linguistics proposal on Area51

2) If the to is part of an adjective + preposition combination: For example:

  • A lot of women aren’t accustomed to being treated so well!
  • I am opposed to increasing taxes. These look similar to the examples above, but you can tell that a word like accustomed is an adjective in this case because there is a form of the verb to be. That is, you are an adjective.

3) If the to is part of a noun + preposition combination: For example:

  • His addiction to gambling has caused a lot of stress for his family.
  • Her great dedication to teaching inspires her students.
4
  • I know the phrasal verb part, but your example 2 is difficult for me. Can I consider "accustomed to", "opposed to " as a phrase verb so I need to add gerund after "to" ?
    – Ives
    Jan 12, 2018 at 4:41
  • If I change the sentence to "I opposed to increase taxes", Is this correct?
    – Ives
    Jan 12, 2018 at 4:49
  • No, they’re not. “Accustomed , opposed ” are adjectives that go with certain preposition look into the following link and you would realize which adjective goes goes with which preposition; google.jo/… Jan 12, 2018 at 13:15
  • thank you, Is the sentence "I oppose to increase taxes" correct?
    – Ives
    Jan 15, 2018 at 2:43

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .