0

I didn't like the tiny size of the room we were given with a balcony same size as the room.

What does this sentence mean? Does it mean:

I didn't like the tiny size of the room that we had. The room's size was the same as that of a balcony.

or

I didn't like the tiny size of the room we had. The room had a balcony, and the balcony's size was the same as that of the room.

I think the latter one is correct, but I want to be sure.

I read this somewhere from a review website. It's not clear where I read it because it's been a while. I didn't understand it clearly then, so I wrote it down and I'm asking about its meaning now.

0

1 Answer 1

0

The given sentence:

I didn't like the tiny size of the room we were given with a balcony same size as the room.

is a bit unclear. I think it should have been written as:

I didn't like the tiny size of the room we were given, with a balcony the same size as the room.

This would mean that the room had a balcony, and the balcony was the same size as the room itself, presumably a rather small size, sine the speaker called it "tiny". Since there is no standard size for a balcony -- they are often small, but can be large in some cases -- comparing the room's size to that of a purely hypothetical balcony, one that does not actually exist, doesn't make much sense. Besides if that were the intent, it would be written more like:

I didn't like the tiny size of the room we were given; it was no bigger than a balcony.

That would make the comparison to a generic balcony clearer.

So I think your second meaning is correct.

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .