Skip to main content
Post Made Community Wiki by StoneyB on hiatus
replaced http://ell.stackexchange.com/ with https://ell.stackexchange.com/
Source Link

Questions about constructing a perfect correctly
   Haven't eaten/haven't ateHaven't eaten/haven't ate
   Confusion with had + forgetConfusion with had + forget
   "I have ever went to""I have ever went to"
   "Is not being" vs "Has not being""Is not being" vs "Has not being"
   "Had remained" vs "Had been remained""Had remained" vs "Had been remained"
   Using "verb + ed" for the futureUsing "verb + ed" for the future
   "I done" vs "I have done""I done" vs "I have done"

Questions about distinguishing perfect constructions
   "Read and accepted" or "read and accept"?"Read and accepted" or "read and accept"?
   People who have had their belongings taken.People who have had their belongings taken.
   What role does this PaPpl take?What role does this PaPpl take?
   Can a living person "have left" a family?Can a living person "have left" a family?

Questions about perfect tense
   Why is the past perfect used in this sentence?Why is the past perfect used in this sentence?
   How often do you use FuPf?How often do you use FuPf?
   Application of 'will' + PrPf constructionsApplication of 'will' + PrPf constructions
   Difference between "has + verbed" and "had + verbed"Difference between "has + verbed" and "had + verbed"
   Time references with Pa and PaPfTime references with Pa and PaPf
   Can PrPf be used with a dead subject?Can PrPf be used with a dead subject?
   Pf used to say one action happened before anotherPf used to say one action happened before another

Questions about perfect aspect
   Does 'had been' imply ongoing action?Does 'had been' imply ongoing action?
   Does Pf imply incompleteness?Does Pf imply incompleteness?
   Does PrPfPrg imply temporary action?Does PrPfPrg imply temporary action?
   Is Pf appropriate with "forget to"?Is Pf appropriate with "forget to"?
   Is Pf appropriate with "break this rule"?Is Pf appropriate with "break this rule"?
   Does "how do you know" have Pf implication?Does "how do you know" have Pf implication?

Questions about modal, irrealis and conditional perfects
   How could he have been so stupid?How could he have been so stupid?
   I would not now have exchanged …I would not now have exchanged …
   I might/may have sat there I might/may have sat there
   I couldn't tell/have told if he was annoyedI couldn't tell/have told if he was annoyed
   Might have been but wasn'tMight have been but wasn't
   My dog could jump/could have jumpedMy dog could jump/could have jumped
   "be going to" in FuPf"be going to" in FuPf
   He will have been drinking all dayHe will have been drinking all day
   He had to have arrivedHe had to have arrived
   I may beat him now/tomorrow .. I might beat him a year agoI may beat him now/tomorrow .. I might beat him a year ago
   Subjunctive had/had hadSubjunctive had/had had
   If I were … I would have … If I were … I would have …
   Modal conditional perfectModal conditional perfect
   Would have been/causedWould have been/caused
   Conditionals with PrPf consequenceConditionals with PrPf consequence
   Conditionals with modal Pf consequenceConditionals with modal Pf consequence
   If I were … I would have madeIf I were … I would have made
   If they had gone … I'd rather you had goneIf they had gone … I'd rather you had gone

Questions about the kinds of perfect meaning
   Something I may still do - haven't or didn'tSomething I may still do - haven't or didn't
   Simple past with consequencesSimple past with consequences
   Because he told/has told me so.Because he told/has told me so.
   Can PrPf be used with a stopped action?Can PrPf be used with a stopped action?
   PrPf or simple past?PrPf or simple past?
   What tense should I use?What tense should I use?
   Why is it not OK to use the PrPf here?Why is it not OK to use the PrPf here?

Questions about choosing between perfect constructions and simple present or past constructions
   I never met him/have never met himI never met him/have never met him
   PrPf/PaPf/Pa with no relation to presentPrPf/PaPf/Pa with no relation to present
   Which tense with recent past?Which tense with recent past?
   is/has been on the newsis/has been on the news
   I am/have been a fanI am/have been a fan
   is/has been a tough dayis/has been a tough day
   issues we face/have facedissues we face/have faced
   Did not expect/Had not expectedDid not expect/Had not expected
   Is being/has been developedIs being/has been developed
   Why didn't he make/hasn't he made the decisionWhy didn't he make/hasn't he made the decision

Questions about coordinating the use of perfect constructions with clauses using other verb constructions
   Before he came/had come .. Tom had studied/was studyingBefore he came/had come .. Tom had studied/was studying
   Making sense of shifting tensesMaking sense of shifting tenses
   When is PaPf not necessary?When is PaPf not necessary?
   What tense(s) with successive past events?What tense(s) with successive past events?
   May we mix different tenses?May we mix different tenses?
   When is the PaPf exactly needed?When is the PaPf exactly needed?
   Chronological order of tensesChronological order of tenses
   I met/had met you before you met/had met herI met/had met you before you met/had met her
   Tense in a clause embedded in a PaPf main clauseTense in a clause embedded in a PaPf main clause
   Should I use the PaPpl of every verb that follows 'would have'?Should I use the PaPpl of every verb that follows 'would have'?
   This is/was/will be the first time I have been/had been/go toThis is/was/will be the first time I have been/had been/go to
   PaPf with past events out of orderPaPf with past events out of order

Questions about the use of perfect constructions with time expressions
   PaPfPrg with 'during'PaPfPrg with 'during'
   Pf with ‘as soon’, ‘when’Pf with ‘as soon’, ‘when’
   Pf with 'ever'Pf with 'ever'
   PrPf with 'until'PrPf with 'until'
   PrPf with 'ever since'PrPf with 'ever since'
   Tense with 'so far'Tense with 'so far'
   Does 'before' make the Pf redundant?Does 'before' make the Pf redundant?
   PrPf with past timePrPf with past time
   Pr with 'always'Pr with 'always'
   Was/has been injured 'for a week now'Was/has been injured 'for a week now'
   Pf with 'for' but now endedPf with 'for' but now ended

Questions about constructing a perfect correctly
   Haven't eaten/haven't ate
   Confusion with had + forget
   "I have ever went to"
   "Is not being" vs "Has not being"
   "Had remained" vs "Had been remained"
   Using "verb + ed" for the future
   "I done" vs "I have done"

Questions about distinguishing perfect constructions
   "Read and accepted" or "read and accept"?
   People who have had their belongings taken.
   What role does this PaPpl take?
   Can a living person "have left" a family?

Questions about perfect tense
   Why is the past perfect used in this sentence?
   How often do you use FuPf?
   Application of 'will' + PrPf constructions
   Difference between "has + verbed" and "had + verbed"
   Time references with Pa and PaPf
   Can PrPf be used with a dead subject?
   Pf used to say one action happened before another

Questions about perfect aspect
   Does 'had been' imply ongoing action?
   Does Pf imply incompleteness?
   Does PrPfPrg imply temporary action?
   Is Pf appropriate with "forget to"?
   Is Pf appropriate with "break this rule"?
   Does "how do you know" have Pf implication?

Questions about modal, irrealis and conditional perfects
   How could he have been so stupid?
   I would not now have exchanged …
   I might/may have sat there
   I couldn't tell/have told if he was annoyed
   Might have been but wasn't
   My dog could jump/could have jumped
   "be going to" in FuPf
   He will have been drinking all day
   He had to have arrived
   I may beat him now/tomorrow .. I might beat him a year ago
   Subjunctive had/had had
   If I were … I would have …
   Modal conditional perfect
   Would have been/caused
   Conditionals with PrPf consequence
   Conditionals with modal Pf consequence
   If I were … I would have made
   If they had gone … I'd rather you had gone

Questions about the kinds of perfect meaning
   Something I may still do - haven't or didn't
   Simple past with consequences
   Because he told/has told me so.
   Can PrPf be used with a stopped action?
   PrPf or simple past?
   What tense should I use?
   Why is it not OK to use the PrPf here?

Questions about choosing between perfect constructions and simple present or past constructions
   I never met him/have never met him
   PrPf/PaPf/Pa with no relation to present
   Which tense with recent past?
   is/has been on the news
   I am/have been a fan
   is/has been a tough day
   issues we face/have faced
   Did not expect/Had not expected
   Is being/has been developed
   Why didn't he make/hasn't he made the decision

Questions about coordinating the use of perfect constructions with clauses using other verb constructions
   Before he came/had come .. Tom had studied/was studying
   Making sense of shifting tenses
   When is PaPf not necessary?
   What tense(s) with successive past events?
   May we mix different tenses?
   When is the PaPf exactly needed?
   Chronological order of tenses
   I met/had met you before you met/had met her
   Tense in a clause embedded in a PaPf main clause
   Should I use the PaPpl of every verb that follows 'would have'?
   This is/was/will be the first time I have been/had been/go to
   PaPf with past events out of order

Questions about the use of perfect constructions with time expressions
   PaPfPrg with 'during'
   Pf with ‘as soon’, ‘when’
   Pf with 'ever'
   PrPf with 'until'
   PrPf with 'ever since'
   Tense with 'so far'
   Does 'before' make the Pf redundant?
   PrPf with past time
   Pr with 'always'
   Was/has been injured 'for a week now'
   Pf with 'for' but now ended

Questions about constructing a perfect correctly
   Haven't eaten/haven't ate
   Confusion with had + forget
   "I have ever went to"
   "Is not being" vs "Has not being"
   "Had remained" vs "Had been remained"
   Using "verb + ed" for the future
   "I done" vs "I have done"

Questions about distinguishing perfect constructions
   "Read and accepted" or "read and accept"?
   People who have had their belongings taken.
   What role does this PaPpl take?
   Can a living person "have left" a family?

Questions about perfect tense
   Why is the past perfect used in this sentence?
   How often do you use FuPf?
   Application of 'will' + PrPf constructions
   Difference between "has + verbed" and "had + verbed"
   Time references with Pa and PaPf
   Can PrPf be used with a dead subject?
   Pf used to say one action happened before another

Questions about perfect aspect
   Does 'had been' imply ongoing action?
   Does Pf imply incompleteness?
   Does PrPfPrg imply temporary action?
   Is Pf appropriate with "forget to"?
   Is Pf appropriate with "break this rule"?
   Does "how do you know" have Pf implication?

Questions about modal, irrealis and conditional perfects
   How could he have been so stupid?
   I would not now have exchanged …
   I might/may have sat there
   I couldn't tell/have told if he was annoyed
   Might have been but wasn't
   My dog could jump/could have jumped
   "be going to" in FuPf
   He will have been drinking all day
   He had to have arrived
   I may beat him now/tomorrow .. I might beat him a year ago
   Subjunctive had/had had
   If I were … I would have …
   Modal conditional perfect
   Would have been/caused
   Conditionals with PrPf consequence
   Conditionals with modal Pf consequence
   If I were … I would have made
   If they had gone … I'd rather you had gone

Questions about the kinds of perfect meaning
   Something I may still do - haven't or didn't
   Simple past with consequences
   Because he told/has told me so.
   Can PrPf be used with a stopped action?
   PrPf or simple past?
   What tense should I use?
   Why is it not OK to use the PrPf here?

Questions about choosing between perfect constructions and simple present or past constructions
   I never met him/have never met him
   PrPf/PaPf/Pa with no relation to present
   Which tense with recent past?
   is/has been on the news
   I am/have been a fan
   is/has been a tough day
   issues we face/have faced
   Did not expect/Had not expected
   Is being/has been developed
   Why didn't he make/hasn't he made the decision

Questions about coordinating the use of perfect constructions with clauses using other verb constructions
   Before he came/had come .. Tom had studied/was studying
   Making sense of shifting tenses
   When is PaPf not necessary?
   What tense(s) with successive past events?
   May we mix different tenses?
   When is the PaPf exactly needed?
   Chronological order of tenses
   I met/had met you before you met/had met her
   Tense in a clause embedded in a PaPf main clause
   Should I use the PaPpl of every verb that follows 'would have'?
   This is/was/will be the first time I have been/had been/go to
   PaPf with past events out of order

Questions about the use of perfect constructions with time expressions
   PaPfPrg with 'during'
   Pf with ‘as soon’, ‘when’
   Pf with 'ever'
   PrPf with 'until'
   PrPf with 'ever since'
   Tense with 'so far'
   Does 'before' make the Pf redundant?
   PrPf with past time
   Pr with 'always'
   Was/has been injured 'for a week now'
   Pf with 'for' but now ended

Mod Removes Wiki by WendiKidd
Source Link
StoneyB on hiatus
  • 175.5k
  • 14
  • 261
  • 463

5. ELL questions about the perfect

This is not a complete list of ELL questions addressing the PF but it should help you find questions similar to yours.

Questions about constructing a perfect correctly
   Haven't eaten/haven't ate
   Confusion with had + forget
   "I have ever went to"
   "Is not being" vs "Has not being"
   "Had remained" vs "Had been remained"
   Using "verb + ed" for the future
   "I done" vs "I have done"

Questions about distinguishing perfect constructions
   "Read and accepted" or "read and accept"?
   People who have had their belongings taken.
   What role does this PaPpl take?
   Can a living person "have left" a family?

Questions about perfect tense
   Why is the past perfect used in this sentence?
   How often do you use FuPf?
   Application of 'will' + PrPf constructions
   Difference between "has + verbed" and "had + verbed"
   Time references with Pa and PaPf
   Can PrPf be used with a dead subject?
   Pf used to say one action happened before another

Questions about perfect aspect
   Does 'had been' imply ongoing action?
   Does Pf imply incompleteness?
   Does PrPfPrg imply temporary action?
   Is Pf appropriate with "forget to"?
   Is Pf appropriate with "break this rule"?
   Does "how do you know" have Pf implication?

Questions about modal, irrealis and conditional perfects
   How could he have been so stupid?
   I would not now have exchanged …
   I might/may have sat there
   I couldn't tell/have told if he was annoyed
   Might have been but wasn't
   My dog could jump/could have jumped
   "be going to" in FuPf
   He will have been drinking all day
   He had to have arrived
   I may beat him now/tomorrow .. I might beat him a year ago
   Subjunctive had/had had
   If I were … I would have …
   Modal conditional perfect
   Would have been/caused
   Conditionals with PrPf consequence
   Conditionals with modal Pf consequence
   If I were … I would have made
   If they had gone … I'd rather you had gone

Questions about the kinds of perfect meaning
   Something I may still do - haven't or didn't
   Simple past with consequences
   Because he told/has told me so.
   Can PrPf be used with a stopped action?
   PrPf or simple past?
   What tense should I use?
   Why is it not OK to use the PrPf here?

Questions about choosing between perfect constructions and simple present or past constructions
   I never met him/have never met him
   PrPf/PaPf/Pa with no relation to present
   Which tense with recent past?
   is/has been on the news
   I am/have been a fan
   is/has been a tough day
   issues we face/have faced
   Did not expect/Had not expected
   Is being/has been developed
   Why didn't he make/hasn't he made the decision

Questions about coordinating the use of perfect constructions with clauses using other verb constructions
   Before he came/had come .. Tom had studied/was studying
   Making sense of shifting tenses
   When is PaPf not necessary?
   What tense(s) with successive past events?
   May we mix different tenses?
   When is the PaPf exactly needed?
   Chronological order of tenses
   I met/had met you before you met/had met her
   Tense in a clause embedded in a PaPf main clause
   Should I use the PaPpl of every verb that follows 'would have'?
   This is/was/will be the first time I have been/had been/go to
   PaPf with past events out of order

Questions about the use of perfect constructions with time expressions
   PaPfPrg with 'during'
   Pf with ‘as soon’, ‘when’
   Pf with 'ever'
   PrPf with 'until'
   PrPf with 'ever since'
   Tense with 'so far'
   Does 'before' make the Pf redundant?
   PrPf with past time
   Pr with 'always'
   Was/has been injured 'for a week now'
   Pf with 'for' but now ended