Return to Question

In LABR, it says

At some moments, Junkyard Planet’s celebration of the ingenuity of the scrap grubbers and swipes at environmental and labor advocates can feel like an overly enthusiastic embrace of an economic system that distributes justice far less efficiently than it does junk.

Does this sentence means the following?

1. Junkyard Planet’s celebration of the ingenuity of the scrap grubbers.

   Junkyard Planet’s swipes at [environmental and labor advocates].

2. We feel the two things in 1 are an overly enthusiastic embrace of an economic system.

3. We think this economic system's ability to distribute justice is far worse than junk's ability to distribute justice.

4. This thought (in 3) is different from what the the book Junkyard Planet wants to say originally. (In fact this book might say this economic system is pretty good)

In LABR, it says

At some moments, Junkyard Planet’s celebration of the ingenuity of the scrap grubbers and swipes at environmental and labor advocates can feel like an overly enthusiastic embrace of an economic system that distributes justice far less efficiently than it does junk.

Does this sentence means the following?

1. Junkyard Planet’s celebration of the ingenuity of the scrap grubbers.

   Junkyard Planet’s swipes at [environmental and labor advocates].

2. We feel the two things in 1 are an overly enthusiastic embrace of an economic system.

3. We think this economic system's ability to distribute justice is far worse than its ability to distribute junk.

4. This thought (in 3) is different from what the the book Junkyard Planet wants to say originally. (In fact this book might say this economic system is pretty good)

In LABR, it says

At some moments, Junkyard Planet’s celebration of the ingenuity of the scrap grubbers and swipes at environmental and labor advocates can feel like an overly enthusiastic embrace of an economic system that distributes justice far less efficiently than it does junk.

Does this sentence means the following?

1. Junkyard Planet’s celebration of the ingenuity of the scrap grubbers.

   Junkyard Planet’s swipes at environmental

   Junkyard Planet’s labor advocates.

2. We feel the three things in 1 are an overly enthusiastic embrace of an economic system.

3. We think this economic system's ability to distribute justice is far worse than junk's ability to distribute justice.

4. This thought (in 3) is different from what the the book Junkyard Planet wants to say originally. (In fact this book might say this economic system is pretty good)

In LABR, it says

At some moments, Junkyard Planet’s celebration of the ingenuity of the scrap grubbers and swipes at environmental and labor advocates can feel like an overly enthusiastic embrace of an economic system that distributes justice far less efficiently than it does junk.

Does this sentence means the following?

1. Junkyard Planet’s celebration of the ingenuity of the scrap grubbers.

   Junkyard Planet’s swipes at [environmental and labor advocates].

2. We feel the two things in 1 are an overly enthusiastic embrace of an economic system.

3. We think this economic system's ability to distribute justice is far worse than junk's ability to distribute justice.

4. This thought (in 3) is different from what the the book Junkyard Planet wants to say originally. (In fact this book might say this economic system is pretty good)

In [LABR][1], it says

Junkyard Planet’s celebration of the ingenuity of the scrap grubbers and swipes at environmental and labor advocates can feel like an overly enthusiastic embrace of an economic system that distributes justice far less efficiently than it does junk.

Does this sentence means

{1.Junkyard Planet’s celebration of the ingenuity of the scrap grubbers. 2.Junkyard Planet’s swipes at environmental. 3.Junkyard Planet’s labor advocates.}

We feel the three things above are an overly enthusiastic embrace of an economic system.

We think this economic system's ability to distribute justice is far worse than junk's ability to distribute justice, and this thought is different from what the the book Junkyard Planet wants to say originally. (In fact this book might say this economic system is pretty good)

? [1]: http://lareviewofbooks.org/review/the-afterlives-of-discarded-objects-adam-minters-junkyard-planet

In LABR, it says

At some moments, Junkyard Planet’s celebration of the ingenuity of the scrap grubbers and swipes at environmental and labor advocates can feel like an overly enthusiastic embrace of an economic system that distributes justice far less efficiently than it does junk.

Does this sentence means the following?

1. Junkyard Planet’s celebration of the ingenuity of the scrap grubbers.

   Junkyard Planet’s swipes at environmental

   Junkyard Planet’s labor advocates.

2. We feel the three things in 1 are an overly enthusiastic embrace of an economic system.

3. We think this economic system's ability to distribute justice is far worse than junk's ability to distribute justice.

4. This thought (in 3) is different from what the the book Junkyard Planet wants to say originally. (In fact this book might say this economic system is pretty good)