Skip to main content
added 511 characters in body
Source Link

Acutally, the situation is not that straightforward: it depends on whether the condition is time-bound or perpetual.

TIME-BOUND EXAMPLES

If I had the money, I would take a vacation to some place warm this coming winter.

If I had had the money at the time, I would have gone to Tahiti before I got married and we had kids.

INNATE "PERPETUAL" CONDITION EXAMPLES

If he had a brain, he would sell that car and buy something reliable.

If he had a brain, he would not have bought that car in the first place.

It is not truly idiomatic to say "If he had had a brain..." although it is grammatical.

Your example is tricky in that it is an either/or condition, one of which is a time-bound condition, "the blueprint", the other, "a brain", a perpetual condition. It's a bad question in that regard.

P.S. Further on the "innate" qualities. To my AmE, they call for an irrealis construction with were. If you had not been so pale-skinned, you wouldn't have gotten such a bad sunburn. That sounds unidiomatic to me, though I recognize it as grammatical; I'd want to use were there: If you weren't so pale-skinned, you wouldn't have gotten such a bad sunburn. Same with If I'd been you, I wouldn't have bought that car. The tense had been sounds wooden and I'd use were there.

Acutally, the situation is not that straightforward: it depends on whether the condition is time-bound or perpetual.

TIME-BOUND EXAMPLES

If I had the money, I would take a vacation to some place warm this coming winter.

If I had had the money at the time, I would have gone to Tahiti before I got married and we had kids.

INNATE "PERPETUAL" CONDITION EXAMPLES

If he had a brain, he would sell that car and buy something reliable.

If he had a brain, he would not have bought that car in the first place.

It is not truly idiomatic to say "If he had had a brain..." although it is grammatical.

Your example is tricky in that it is an either/or condition, one of which is a time-bound condition, "the blueprint", the other, "a brain", a perpetual condition. It's a bad question in that regard.

Acutally, the situation is not that straightforward: it depends on whether the condition is time-bound or perpetual.

TIME-BOUND EXAMPLES

If I had the money, I would take a vacation to some place warm this coming winter.

If I had had the money at the time, I would have gone to Tahiti before I got married and we had kids.

INNATE "PERPETUAL" CONDITION EXAMPLES

If he had a brain, he would sell that car and buy something reliable.

If he had a brain, he would not have bought that car in the first place.

It is not truly idiomatic to say "If he had had a brain..." although it is grammatical.

Your example is tricky in that it is an either/or condition, one of which is a time-bound condition, "the blueprint", the other, "a brain", a perpetual condition. It's a bad question in that regard.

P.S. Further on the "innate" qualities. To my AmE, they call for an irrealis construction with were. If you had not been so pale-skinned, you wouldn't have gotten such a bad sunburn. That sounds unidiomatic to me, though I recognize it as grammatical; I'd want to use were there: If you weren't so pale-skinned, you wouldn't have gotten such a bad sunburn. Same with If I'd been you, I wouldn't have bought that car. The tense had been sounds wooden and I'd use were there.

added 187 characters in body
Source Link

Acutally, the situation is not that straightforward: it depends on whether the condition is time-bound or perpetual.

TIME-BOUND EXAMPLES

If I had the money, I would take a vacation to some place warm this coming winter.

If I had had the money at the time, I would have gone to Tahiti before I got married and we had kids.

INNATE "PERPETUAL" CONDITION EXAMPLES

If he had a brain, he would sell that car and buy something reliable.

If he had a brain, he would not have bought that car in the first place.

It is not truly idiomatic to say "If he had had a brain..." although it is grammatical.

Your example is tricky in that it is an either/or condition, one of which is a time-bound condition, "the blueprint", the other, "a brain", a perpetual condition. It's a bad question in that regard.

Acutally, the situation is not that straightforward: it depends on whether the condition is time-bound or perpetual.

TIME-BOUND EXAMPLES

If I had the money, I would take a vacation to some place warm this coming winter.

If I had had the money at the time, I would have gone to Tahiti before I got married and we had kids.

INNATE "PERPETUAL" CONDITION EXAMPLES

If he had a brain, he would sell that car and buy something reliable.

If he had a brain, he would not have bought that car in the first place.

It is not truly idiomatic to say "If he had had a brain..." although it is grammatical.

Acutally, the situation is not that straightforward: it depends on whether the condition is time-bound or perpetual.

TIME-BOUND EXAMPLES

If I had the money, I would take a vacation to some place warm this coming winter.

If I had had the money at the time, I would have gone to Tahiti before I got married and we had kids.

INNATE "PERPETUAL" CONDITION EXAMPLES

If he had a brain, he would sell that car and buy something reliable.

If he had a brain, he would not have bought that car in the first place.

It is not truly idiomatic to say "If he had had a brain..." although it is grammatical.

Your example is tricky in that it is an either/or condition, one of which is a time-bound condition, "the blueprint", the other, "a brain", a perpetual condition. It's a bad question in that regard.

Source Link

Acutally, the situation is not that straightforward: it depends on whether the condition is time-bound or perpetual.

TIME-BOUND EXAMPLES

If I had the money, I would take a vacation to some place warm this coming winter.

If I had had the money at the time, I would have gone to Tahiti before I got married and we had kids.

INNATE "PERPETUAL" CONDITION EXAMPLES

If he had a brain, he would sell that car and buy something reliable.

If he had a brain, he would not have bought that car in the first place.

It is not truly idiomatic to say "If he had had a brain..." although it is grammatical.