Skip to main content
Commonmark migration
Source Link

Is this sentence correct?

 
  1. Although I would like to start, nevertheless it is not possible.
 

Or should it be:

 
  1. Although I would like to start, it is not possible.
  2. I would like to start, nevertheless it is not possible.

Your example #1 is fine.

Consider this example from the 2002 CGEL, page 776, example [2.iii ], which is structured very similar to your example:

[2.iii ] Although he affects a gruff exterior in many instances, nevertheless he is fundamentally a man of warm heart and gentle disposition.

and their explanation:

Another very common case is represented in [2.iii ], where the connective adjunct has a reduplicative role: the relation between the main and subordinate clauses is already marked by although, so that nevertheless simply marks this relationship a second time.


ASIDE: As to your other two examples, example #2 is fine; but example #3 might be a bit controversial in that some people might see it as being a comma splice, and so they might expect or demand a semicolon or period or em dash to be used instead of a comma. Example #3 is okay to me for informal style, but if I'm writing in a very formal style or for a formal register then I might think twice before using a comma there like that.


NOTE: The 2002 CGEL is the 2002 reference grammar by Huddleston and Pullum (et al.), The Cambridge Grammar of the English Language.

Is this sentence correct?

 
  1. Although I would like to start, nevertheless it is not possible.
 

Or should it be:

 
  1. Although I would like to start, it is not possible.
  2. I would like to start, nevertheless it is not possible.

Your example #1 is fine.

Consider this example from the 2002 CGEL, page 776, example [2.iii ], which is structured very similar to your example:

[2.iii ] Although he affects a gruff exterior in many instances, nevertheless he is fundamentally a man of warm heart and gentle disposition.

and their explanation:

Another very common case is represented in [2.iii ], where the connective adjunct has a reduplicative role: the relation between the main and subordinate clauses is already marked by although, so that nevertheless simply marks this relationship a second time.


ASIDE: As to your other two examples, example #2 is fine; but example #3 might be a bit controversial in that some people might see it as being a comma splice, and so they might expect or demand a semicolon or period or em dash to be used instead of a comma. Example #3 is okay to me for informal style, but if I'm writing in a very formal style or for a formal register then I might think twice before using a comma there like that.


NOTE: The 2002 CGEL is the 2002 reference grammar by Huddleston and Pullum (et al.), The Cambridge Grammar of the English Language.

Is this sentence correct?

  1. Although I would like to start, nevertheless it is not possible.

Or should it be:

  1. Although I would like to start, it is not possible.
  2. I would like to start, nevertheless it is not possible.

Your example #1 is fine.

Consider this example from the 2002 CGEL, page 776, example [2.iii ], which is structured very similar to your example:

[2.iii ] Although he affects a gruff exterior in many instances, nevertheless he is fundamentally a man of warm heart and gentle disposition.

and their explanation:

Another very common case is represented in [2.iii ], where the connective adjunct has a reduplicative role: the relation between the main and subordinate clauses is already marked by although, so that nevertheless simply marks this relationship a second time.


ASIDE: As to your other two examples, example #2 is fine; but example #3 might be a bit controversial in that some people might see it as being a comma splice, and so they might expect or demand a semicolon or period or em dash to be used instead of a comma. Example #3 is okay to me for informal style, but if I'm writing in a very formal style or for a formal register then I might think twice before using a comma there like that.


NOTE: The 2002 CGEL is the 2002 reference grammar by Huddleston and Pullum (et al.), The Cambridge Grammar of the English Language.

added 11 characters in body
Source Link
F.E.
  • 5k
  • 1
  • 22
  • 40

Is this sentence correct?

  1. Although I would like to start, nevertheless it is not possible.

Or should it be:

  1. Although I would like to start, it is not possible.
  2. I would like to start, nevertheless it is not possible.

Your example #1 is fine.

Consider this example from the 2002 CGEL, page 776, example [2.iii ], which is structured very similar to your example:

[2.iii ] Although he affects a gruff exterior in many instances, nevertheless he is fundamentally a man of warm heart and gentle disposition.

and their explanation:

Another very common case is represented in [2.iii ], where the connective adjunct has a reduplicative role: the relation between the main and subordinate clauses is already marked by although, so that nevertheless simply marks this relationship a second time.


ASIDE: As to your other two examples, example #2 is fine; but example #3 might be a bit controversial in that some people might see it as being a comma splice, and so they might expect or demand a semicolon or period or em dash to be used instead of a comma. Example #3 is okay to me for informal style, but if I'm writing in a very formal style or for a formal register then I might think twice before using a comma there like that.


NOTE: The 2002 CGEL is the 2002 reference grammar by Huddleston and Pullum (et al.), The Cambridge Grammar of the English Language.

Is this sentence correct?

  1. Although I would like to start, nevertheless it is not possible.

Or should it be:

  1. Although I would like to start, it is not possible.
  2. I would like to start, nevertheless it is not possible.

Your example #1 is fine.

Consider this example from the 2002 CGEL, page 776, example [2.iii ], which is structured very similar to your example:

[2.iii ] Although he affects a gruff exterior in many instances, nevertheless he is fundamentally a man of warm heart and gentle disposition.

and their explanation:

Another very common case is represented in [2.iii ], where the connective adjunct has a reduplicative role: the relation between the main and subordinate clauses is already marked by although, so that nevertheless simply marks this relationship a second time.


ASIDE: As to your other two examples, example #2 is fine; but example #3 might be a bit controversial in that some people might see it as being a comma splice, and so they might expect or demand a semicolon or period to be used instead of a comma. Example #3 is okay to me for informal style, but if I'm writing in a very formal style or for a formal register then I might think twice before using a comma there like that.


NOTE: The 2002 CGEL is the 2002 reference grammar by Huddleston and Pullum (et al.), The Cambridge Grammar of the English Language.

Is this sentence correct?

  1. Although I would like to start, nevertheless it is not possible.

Or should it be:

  1. Although I would like to start, it is not possible.
  2. I would like to start, nevertheless it is not possible.

Your example #1 is fine.

Consider this example from the 2002 CGEL, page 776, example [2.iii ], which is structured very similar to your example:

[2.iii ] Although he affects a gruff exterior in many instances, nevertheless he is fundamentally a man of warm heart and gentle disposition.

and their explanation:

Another very common case is represented in [2.iii ], where the connective adjunct has a reduplicative role: the relation between the main and subordinate clauses is already marked by although, so that nevertheless simply marks this relationship a second time.


ASIDE: As to your other two examples, example #2 is fine; but example #3 might be a bit controversial in that some people might see it as being a comma splice, and so they might expect or demand a semicolon or period or em dash to be used instead of a comma. Example #3 is okay to me for informal style, but if I'm writing in a very formal style or for a formal register then I might think twice before using a comma there like that.


NOTE: The 2002 CGEL is the 2002 reference grammar by Huddleston and Pullum (et al.), The Cambridge Grammar of the English Language.

Source Link
F.E.
  • 5k
  • 1
  • 22
  • 40

Is this sentence correct?

  1. Although I would like to start, nevertheless it is not possible.

Or should it be:

  1. Although I would like to start, it is not possible.
  2. I would like to start, nevertheless it is not possible.

Your example #1 is fine.

Consider this example from the 2002 CGEL, page 776, example [2.iii ], which is structured very similar to your example:

[2.iii ] Although he affects a gruff exterior in many instances, nevertheless he is fundamentally a man of warm heart and gentle disposition.

and their explanation:

Another very common case is represented in [2.iii ], where the connective adjunct has a reduplicative role: the relation between the main and subordinate clauses is already marked by although, so that nevertheless simply marks this relationship a second time.


ASIDE: As to your other two examples, example #2 is fine; but example #3 might be a bit controversial in that some people might see it as being a comma splice, and so they might expect or demand a semicolon or period to be used instead of a comma. Example #3 is okay to me for informal style, but if I'm writing in a very formal style or for a formal register then I might think twice before using a comma there like that.


NOTE: The 2002 CGEL is the 2002 reference grammar by Huddleston and Pullum (et al.), The Cambridge Grammar of the English Language.