Skip to main content
improved formatting
Source Link
WendiKidd
  • 14.6k
  • 4
  • 43
  • 68

To elaborate a bit on some parts of Emmabee's answer: the reason that your second example sounds a bit off rather than entirely incorrect is because the verb "stand" can imply either a state of being or an action, and in this case the default sense is a state of being. For example, this sounds fine:

If he had stood when the tornado passed over the ditch in which he was lying, it would have killed him.

If he had stood when the tornado passed over the ditch in which he was lying, it would have killed him.

In this case it's clear that standstand implies a change of position. We often clarify this meaning by adding "up": "If he had stood up" and so on.

To elaborate a bit on some parts of Emmabee's answer: the reason that your second example sounds a bit off rather than entirely incorrect is because the verb "stand" can imply either a state of being or an action, and in this case the default sense is a state of being. For example, this sounds fine:

If he had stood when the tornado passed over the ditch in which he was lying, it would have killed him.

In this case it's clear that stand implies a change of position. We often clarify this meaning by adding "up": "If he had stood up" and so on.

To elaborate a bit on some parts of Emmabee's answer: the reason that your second example sounds a bit off rather than entirely incorrect is because the verb "stand" can imply either a state of being or an action, and in this case the default sense is a state of being. For example, this sounds fine:

If he had stood when the tornado passed over the ditch in which he was lying, it would have killed him.

In this case it's clear that stand implies a change of position. We often clarify this meaning by adding "up": "If he had stood up" and so on.

Source Link
BobRodes
  • 15.1k
  • 26
  • 41

To elaborate a bit on some parts of Emmabee's answer: the reason that your second example sounds a bit off rather than entirely incorrect is because the verb "stand" can imply either a state of being or an action, and in this case the default sense is a state of being. For example, this sounds fine:

If he had stood when the tornado passed over the ditch in which he was lying, it would have killed him.

In this case it's clear that stand implies a change of position. We often clarify this meaning by adding "up": "If he had stood up" and so on.