Skip to main content
typo
Source Link
Nico
  • 2.5k
  • 18
  • 47

English 'anaphoric' words - words which 'stand for' other constituents of a sentence - are all called pronouns, but in fact there are two different categories:

  • words which act as placeholders for nominal expressions (he, she, it, what, which, who, this, that &c)
  • words which act as placeholders for adverbial expressions, and might better be called pro-adverbs (how, where, when, why, whither, &c)

But for adjectival expressions we have only the demonstrative such (now little used in this sense;sense) and we have nothing for verbal expressions. Instead we use the pro-nouns and pro-adverbs in various combinations.

  • With adjectives we mostly use how+ADJ or what/which+NOUN as interrogatives/relatives and this/that/so/yay+ADJ or this/that+NOUN as demonstratives.

How big you want that? ... About yay big.
What color shirt was he wearing? ... That color.

  • With verbs we mostly use what/which (interrogative/relative) and this/that (demonstrative), in combination with the all-purpose verb DO.

Whatcha doin? ... Whatchu see.
What do we do? ... What we have to do.

You could make a case for thinking of DO here as a pro-verb and what as its obligatory pronominal object.

English 'anaphoric' words - words which 'stand for' other constituents of a sentence - are all called pronouns, but in fact there are two different categories:

  • words which act as placeholders for nominal expressions (he, she, it, what, which, who, this, that &c)
  • words which act as placeholders for adverbial expressions, and might better be called pro-adverbs (how, where, when, why, whither, &c)

But for adjectival expressions we have only the demonstrative such (now little used in this sense; and we have nothing for verbal expressions. Instead we use the pro-nouns and pro-adverbs in various combinations.

  • With adjectives we mostly use how+ADJ or what/which+NOUN as interrogatives/relatives and this/that/so/yay+ADJ or this/that+NOUN as demonstratives.

How big you want that? ... About yay big.
What color shirt was he wearing? ... That color.

  • With verbs we mostly use what/which (interrogative/relative) and this/that (demonstrative), in combination with the all-purpose verb DO.

Whatcha doin? ... Whatchu see.
What do we do? ... What we have to do.

You could make a case for thinking of DO here as a pro-verb and what as its obligatory pronominal object.

English 'anaphoric' words - words which 'stand for' other constituents of a sentence - are all called pronouns, but in fact there are two different categories:

  • words which act as placeholders for nominal expressions (he, she, it, what, which, who, this, that &c)
  • words which act as placeholders for adverbial expressions, and might better be called pro-adverbs (how, where, when, why, whither, &c)

But for adjectival expressions we have only the demonstrative such (now little used in this sense) and we have nothing for verbal expressions. Instead we use the pro-nouns and pro-adverbs in various combinations.

  • With adjectives we mostly use how+ADJ or what/which+NOUN as interrogatives/relatives and this/that/so/yay+ADJ or this/that+NOUN as demonstratives.

How big you want that? ... About yay big.
What color shirt was he wearing? ... That color.

  • With verbs we mostly use what/which (interrogative/relative) and this/that (demonstrative), in combination with the all-purpose verb DO.

Whatcha doin? ... Whatchu see.
What do we do? ... What we have to do.

You could make a case for thinking of DO here as a pro-verb and what as its obligatory pronominal object.

Source Link
StoneyB on hiatus
  • 175.5k
  • 14
  • 261
  • 463

English 'anaphoric' words - words which 'stand for' other constituents of a sentence - are all called pronouns, but in fact there are two different categories:

  • words which act as placeholders for nominal expressions (he, she, it, what, which, who, this, that &c)
  • words which act as placeholders for adverbial expressions, and might better be called pro-adverbs (how, where, when, why, whither, &c)

But for adjectival expressions we have only the demonstrative such (now little used in this sense; and we have nothing for verbal expressions. Instead we use the pro-nouns and pro-adverbs in various combinations.

  • With adjectives we mostly use how+ADJ or what/which+NOUN as interrogatives/relatives and this/that/so/yay+ADJ or this/that+NOUN as demonstratives.

How big you want that? ... About yay big.
What color shirt was he wearing? ... That color.

  • With verbs we mostly use what/which (interrogative/relative) and this/that (demonstrative), in combination with the all-purpose verb DO.

Whatcha doin? ... Whatchu see.
What do we do? ... What we have to do.

You could make a case for thinking of DO here as a pro-verb and what as its obligatory pronominal object.