0

Do I need to use apostrophe 's in the following sentence? 

  • I left my job in 2007 after a misunderstanding between me and the manager of the company. I joined the the company again in 2009 after my friend*'s* becoming the new manager of the company.

I know we can say the following:

  • I left my job in 2007 after a misunderstanding between me and the manager of the company. I joined the the company again in 2009 after my friend became the new manager of the company.

But should I use apostrophe 's if I use a gerund?

3
  • 2
    Your very use of apostrophes is incorrect. You follow the word apostrophe with a space and... an apostrophe! (Why?) The 's ending is for posessives and abbreviation of is, has, etc, not for plurals. May 14, 2019 at 11:28
  • The plural of apostrophe is apostrophes. By actually using an apostrophe before the s, you are turning it into a possessive. ("Apostrophe's what? What does Apostrophe own?" May 14, 2019 at 14:26
  • He's being a little tautological perhaps, but I wouldn't call it incorrect. It's like saying "Is it alright to use the ampersand & here?"
    – Showsni
    May 14, 2019 at 14:49

1 Answer 1

3

Sure, there are situations when you can use the possessive with a gerund. A gerund is a noun like any other:

As a dedicated vegan, I try not to comment on my friends' eating habits.

This works because "eating habits" is a well-known compound noun that just happens to start with a gerund.

Most of the time, however, the result is confusing or awkward. Your first sentence is a good example. "After my friend's becoming ..." is a complicated way to make what should be a simple, declarative statement.

Another example:

She appreciated her friend's welcoming of the new families into their community.

Again, "her friend's welcoming" is an inelegant phrase. In general, it's better to keep it simple:

She appreciated that her friend welcomed the new families into their community.

or rearrange it to use a more common noun:

She appreciated her friend's welcome of the families into the community.

This last option is something you can do with your example:

I joined the the company again in 2009 after my friend's appointment as the new manager of the company.

Side note: As in any language, there are many ways to say something in English. Different people have different writing styles and might prefer to use the possessive gerund to convey shades of meaning. For example, "welcoming" is also an adjective that means:

behaving in a polite or friendly way to a guest or new arrival

You might choose to write "her friend's welcoming" to suggest that this quality of her friend's personality, or just because you think it sounds better than "welcome".

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .