Please tell me what's meant by the emboldened part

The best innings you ever played? The Lord's Test in 1972, just because of the conditions and the situation of the game [Chappell scored 131 out of 308 to give Australia a narrow first-innings lead]. Technically and mentally it was as good as I'd played. The conditions were very much in favour of the bowlers.

Does it mean that was the best innings he ever played?

  • Yes, but not exactly. It means [as good as] the best innings he had ever played (the word ever is implicit in the cited text). That's to say, he may have played as well in the past, but never better. (There's a strong implication that he did play that well in the past, but this isn't an absolute.) Commented Aug 17, 2016 at 15:26
  • Or could it mean that he thought that he did an excellent job of batting that day given that the conditions weren't ideal from the batter's point of view?
    – Policewala
    Commented Aug 17, 2016 at 16:54
  • You can draw all sorts of implications that aren't explicitly stated. Quite possibly the speaker (Chappell?) knows perfectly that by other people's standards, his performance in 1972 wasn't considered anywhere near his best. He might have chosen to name it as "the best innings" purely because technically and mentally it stood out for him, even though he may have scored far more on many other occasions. But this is all speculation - I still can't see why you have a problem with the basic meaning of the actual words you've highlighted. Commented Aug 17, 2016 at 17:25

1 Answer 1


was as good as I'd played

means it equalled the highest level he had played in the past.

If he had said

was the best I'd ever played.

then it would have been a new personal best.

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .