I saw the following sentence in a book that I'm reading:

"Why do I get my best ideas in the shower?" an exasperated Einstein is said to have remarked.

I was wondering why an indefinite article is used before Einstein. My best guess is that it's because they are referring to one of many states of Einstein (for example, a tired Einstein, a confused Einstein, etc.), but I'm not sure what the grammatical reason behind this is.

I came up with other adjectives that required a definite article "the" before adjective + Einstein, for example, "the newly-wedded Einstein" or "the recently-relocated Einstein". However, I don't understand the rules for why a definite article must be used in these cases and an indefinite article in the earlier cases.


I don't know if there are formal grammatical rules for this usage, but the indefinite article denotes a temporary state, where Einstein may have seemed exasperated when he made the remark. Using a definite article tends to identify a subject that has transitioned to a new state, so there is clearly a before-and-after condition that applies.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.