0

the following sentence shall I add "will"?

People who (will) attend party tonight will take part in the party tonight.

Besides:

The girl who will be my girlfriend will take part in my party.

The man who was killed at 6 P.M. will be found at 10 pm.(now is 3 pm)

1

The first sentence is usually used without will. Using it with will brings will closer to its sense of willingness rather than as an indicator of future time, and so it sounds like

The people who are willing (or show a desire) to attend the party tonight and demonstrate this desire by actually going to it will take part in the party tonight.

The second sentence is the same. It sounds like you do not have a girlfriend when you say the sentence, so you could mean

The girl who is willing to be my girlfriend will take part in my party.

or you could be predicting that some girl will become your girlfriend by tonight.

If you have a girlfriend, just use The girl who is my girlfriend will take part in my party.

In your third sentence will in will be found at 10pm comes across as a strong promise. You would probably not use is found at 10pm unless describing the situation after the girl was found; in this case the use of the present would be the historical present.

  • Thanks so much for your kind help! But I don't know why a grammar book says normally if the main sentence uses simple future tenses, the attributive clause should use simple present tense to express the future. like :"I'll give you everything I find" Is it ambiguous? (1) I will give you everything that I have now. Or something I will get. If I wanna say the lady will be my girl friend, how can I express ? Can I say "The lady who is my girlfriend will be my partner tomorrow? – moyeea Sep 9 '16 at 23:20
  • In I'll give you everything I find, the find refers to future time. The lady who is my girlfriend will be my partner tomorrow is fine. It means the lady who is currently/now my girlfriend. I don't exactly know what you mean by will be my partner (tomorrow). – Alan Carmack Sep 10 '16 at 1:01
  • But how can we tell…the present situation is used in simple present situation,the future situation is used in simple present situation…The meaning is different Thanks so much! – moyeea Sep 10 '16 at 11:56

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.