0

The royal bodyguard has/have deserted en route. In the sentence, which helping verb, has or have, should be used.

  • Why do you think that you should use "have". Would tell us what do you think yourself? – Cardinal Oct 5 '16 at 23:16
  • The word 'bodyguard' has plural meaning, I think. – thein lwin Oct 5 '16 at 23:28
1

The word bodyguard can indicate an individual or a military unit, and it is not clear how you are using it in your example. If you mean a military unit, then you should put:

The royal bodyguard has deserted en route.

However, since desertion is basically an individual act, it might be better to put:

The royal bodyguards have deserted en route.

It all depends on whether they acted individually or together (under command of their officers).

  • 3
    The quirk here is that, mostly in BrE, nouns for groups of people are inherently plural and take the plural form of the verb -- for example "the crowd are" instead of "the crowd is". So the answer depends on whether we're talking BrE or AmE -- in BrE "the royal bodyguard have" ought to be fine if they all deserted as a group. If it was a solo act then the one bodyguard "has deserted". Further reading – Andrew Oct 6 '16 at 4:44
1

The noun "bodyguard" is singular. "Has" is the singular verb.

The royal bodyguard has deserted...

This is correct whether the bodyguard is an individual or a collective noun (which is still singular) for a group of bodyguards.

"Have" is correct for a plural:

The royal bodyguards have deserted...

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.