1
  1. If she (let's call this person X) had said anything to you (let's call this person Y) about her coming over to your place tonight, I would probably drop by your place as well.

  2. If she said anything to you about her coming over to your place tonight, I would probably drop by as well.

Which of these sentences convey, X hasn't said anything to Y about X's coming over to Y's place tonight, which is why I probably won't drop by Y's place., the best.


  • I haven't anything productive this week, I think that's why I'm depressed.

  • If I had done something productive this week, I wouldn't so depressed.

Do the two sentences convey the same information, that he hasn't done anything productive this week, and that he's depressed?

2

If you had asked politely ...

I would probably give you a cookie.

I would probably have given you a cookie.

You did not ask politely, or we're just talking about a past hypothetical.

If you asked politely ...

I might have given you a cookie.

I might give you a cookie.

You may or may not have asked. Requires context to know whether the speaker is talking about what has happened or about what might happen.

  • +1 from me What about: "If Alice had said anything about her coming over to your place tonight, I would have probably dropped by your place as well* " Would that also work? – Mari-Lou A Oct 15 '16 at 7:26
  • @Mari-Lou A: Your sentence could be understood in both ways as well. It is either a statement by the speaker implying that Alice did not say anything, or a hypothetical about what the speaker is likely to have done if the condition in the if-clause were true. The context of the conversation in which the statement is made tells us the speaker's intended meaning, lthough this kind of if-statement can be used to avoid making an unconditional statement. "Were you at the bank on the afternoon of the robbery? --If the shop's proceeds had been deposited by my business partner, I would not ... – Tᴚoɯɐuo Oct 15 '16 at 11:17

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.