1

Would "in my area" be a non-restrictive clause in the sentence, "These are the only two parks I know, in my area"?

2 Answers 2

5

Edited and corrected, thanks to @AlanCarmack:

"In my area" is not a clause, it's a prepositional phrase. "In my area" doesn't have a subject-verb combination and does not form a predicate. Instead, it provides additional context to the clause it is in. "In" is the preposition in this case.

On that note, I think that the comma is incorrect here. The sentence should be, "These are the only two parks I know in my area." In speech, there may be a pause before, "in my area", but this should not be signified by a comma in writing.

You could also write it as "These are the only two parks in my area that I know.

3
  • 1
    With the pause, or the comma that represents it, I would take the restriction as an afterthought: "These are the only two parks I know ... wait, I can't say that, it's nonsense that I only know two parks, I'd better clarify .. in my area".
    – Colin Fine
    Commented Oct 24, 2016 at 20:32
  • "in my area" is a prepositional phrase, not a clause Commented Oct 27, 2016 at 16:12
  • @AlanCarmack, but can't it be considered as the elided form of "which are in my area"? And so the restrictive/nonrestrictive distinction applies, like it does to appositives? // Also, what do you you think of Colin Fine's comment? Wouldn't you consider a comma appropriate there then? Commented Jan 18, 2020 at 10:29
2

In my area is a prepositional phrase. It is not a clause. The whole idea of restrictive and non-restrictive clauses refers only to relative clauses as far as I know, and the insertion of commas is largely stylistic in regard to prepositional phrases. I would never use a comma after know in

These are the only two parks I know in my area

because a comma would totally break up the flow of the sentence.

The true relative clause in this sentence is

[that] I know in my area

and leaving out the relative pronoun that and a comma before it makes the clause restrictive.

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .