1

I have two questions. The first one is: I have heard that I can't use emotional verbs such as "see, hear, love" with -ing, but I want to know how to use it in this sentence:

Yeah, I still seeing her?

After still, do I use -ing like this?

I still loving her.

Do I use

She is looking so bad.

or

She looks so bad.

The second question is: can I say

She has to has.

or

She has to have.

closed as unclear what you're asking by P. E. Dant, Nathan Tuggy, user3169, shin, Varun Nair Nov 17 '16 at 6:55

Please clarify your specific problem or add additional details to highlight exactly what you need. As it's currently written, it’s hard to tell exactly what you're asking. See the How to Ask page for help clarifying this question. If this question can be reworded to fit the rules in the help center, please edit the question.

  • 3
    Can you tell use where you learned that we can't use the gerund of verbs like see, hear, love, etc.? Loving, seeing, and hearing are perfectly correct English gerunds. (We do not use wanna in polite English. It is only acceptable in informal settings such as text messaging among friends. Use want to instead.) – P. E. Dant Nov 16 '16 at 21:34
  • In your own language, it may be correct to say She happy, but English is not the same as your native language. We use the copula or linking verb in sentences like She is happy and I am still loving her. Have you studied the linking verbs like to be? – P. E. Dant Nov 16 '16 at 21:45
  • You shouldn't add information like " I have heard that..." since by itself it is not helpful. You should focus on learning correct English, not copying what someone says which may or may not be correct. – user3169 Nov 17 '16 at 0:32
0

Your question on using see, hear and love in

Yeah, I still seeing her?

can be either "Yeah, I still see her" or "Yeah, I am still seeing her". Adding the word am allows the use of the -ing, but the way the sentences are understood is slightly different.

I still see her

is a statement of fact in the present, but

I am still seeing her

is a statement of fact in the "progressive aspect", meaning that it refers to an action that is in the middle of happening.

This might be easier to understand with other verbs. "I am eating" means that I am in the middle of eating right now, while "I eat" is more of a general statement -- "I eat vegetables every day."

With

I still loving her

to be clear on meaning it can only be

I still love her

The reason is that "I am still loving her" can have mixed meanings depending on how and when it is said.

With your question on whether you can use "She is looking so bad" or "She looks so bad", you can use either sentence and mean the same thing, although in slightly different ways. Again this is in the terms of "statement of fact" and "within the progressive aspect".

The answer to your second question is

She has to have

The main verb to have implies the meaning of possession the auxiliary verb She has is used to help the main verb create the perfect tense.

The auxiliary verbs for to have in the context of

I or you or we or they

are

have in the present tense or had in the past tense

The auxiliary verbs for to have in the context of

he or she or it

are

has in the present tense or have in the past tense.

0

I think the rule you were taught is that you ought not to use the -ing form of "emotional" verbs in the present progressive tense. In English, the verbs "to see", "to hear", "to feel" are not really "emotional", though. I'm not sure how best to categorize these verbs of perception if you group them with "emotional" verbs like "loving".

Moreover there's nothing wrong with using verbs like "to look" or "to listen" in the progressive tense. Remember when using the progressive tense you must use is or are in the sentence. Examples:

I am looking but I don't see her.

Shh! I'm listening to the orchestra.

As with many English words, these verbs have alternate meanings which you may use in the progressive tense. "To see" someone could mean to "to date" someone. If you say, for example:

Are you still seeing her?

you are asking if the person still regularly goes on dates with her. I suggest you look up some of the other words on your list to see if they also have alternate meanings.

The progressive tense indicates a current, ongoing action. If you want to talk about someone's condition, you should use the simple present instead:

She looks very nice today.

I hear he got a new job.

I see that they are still dating.


As for your second question, the "has to/have to" structure (to indicate some kind of necessity) is followed by the bare infinitive form of the verb.

I have to go

I have to sleep

I have to eat.

She has to study.

This holds true even if the very is "to have":

We have to have new clothes if we want to go to that club.

She has to have some better music on her phone.

They have to have a vacation soon.

It may sound weird to say "have to have", but to native English speakers it sounds perfectly natural.

  • These verbs are called verbs of perception. You might consider replacing I'm not sure how best to categorize them with the commonly used term. – P. E. Dant Nov 16 '16 at 23:50
  • @P.E.Dant edited my answer. I meant that I don't know how to categorize them if you lump them in with verbs like loving. – Andrew Nov 16 '16 at 23:59
  • See and hear et al. are verbs of perception. Love, hate, like et al. are stative verbs of emotion. Both kinds of verb (and some others) fail to play well with the present continuous—we don't usually say "I am hating that" or "I am seeing it," which I think is what the OP means by the reference to -ing forms. – P. E. Dant Nov 17 '16 at 0:06

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.