2

"I was not sure which colour is better, so I bought both a red and a white roses"

Is it correct that there are articles and that the verb is plural?

4

Using an article is fine, but the noun has to match the article. "A ____" is singular, but "roses" is plural, so you can't say "a white roses".

If you bought one rose of each color, you could say

I bought a red rose and a white rose

or

I bought a red and a white rose

although I think the second one is informal and less clear than the first. Using the article for each makes it clearer than using no article:

I bought red and white roses

This makes it unclear whether you mean one of each, or many of each, or even if you mean "many roses, each of which were mixed red and white". Using the plural can be OK if there's enough context to make it clear, though. For example,

I offered her a white rose, a red rose, a pink rose, and a yellow rose. She picked up the red and white roses.

Here, from context we already know that there was only one of each color, so "red and white roses" is clear.

| improve this answer | |
  • I thought the plural "roses" matches "both" (not "a rose"). May one use "both" in your variant: "I bought BOTH a red and a white rose"? – Serguei Nov 29 '16 at 19:16
  • 1
    Yes, the plural "roses" matches both, but once you start talking about them individually, they become singular. You can say "I bought roses", but once you start talking about their individual qualities (red or white), you have to use the singular, because there is only one red rose and one white rose. You could use the plural if you were talking about them together ("I dropped the red and white roses") but like I mentioned, it's unclear unless you already know how many of each there were. And yes, you can also say "I bought both a red and a white rose." – stangdon Nov 29 '16 at 19:42

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.