I wrote a sentence under the online news comment section:

I would say he does a good job this time, practically showing he's tough with zero consequence, ideally showing what's normal and should be done.

But I am confused with many things,

  1. he did what I think is a good job before the news is out, so I should use past tense "did", but I was commenting under the latest news section(but still two days old), it's so recent that I feel does is more proper, and to me since I know he did a good job only when I read the news, it's like he just does it a few second ago, so it's more natural to me to use present tense, so what should I use?
  2. In the second half of the sentence, it sounds well to use adverb practically and ideally, but there is no verb there, is this usage valid? Or I have to use comma to separate the sentence? Like "...this time, practically, showing...", but this sounds strange to me.
  • 1. did because in context this statement could only be made after the "job" was completed (when there is only one instance). But you could say "I would say he does a good job most of the time" where the time frame is unspecified. – user3169 Dec 5 '16 at 6:34

If you are commenting on a news article that relates what a person did, you should say

He did a good job

If you want to say that someone habitually does quality work, you would say

He does a good job

The fact that you read about it only recently is not relevant.

I'm a little confused by the second part of your question. First there is a verb there: practically and ideally modify the verb showing. Second, practically has two meanings: almost and in a practical manner. Used in the first way:

He practically ran all the way home.

Used in the second way:

Practically, it's too far to walk

If you mean to use it in the second way, which I think you do, it would be clearer if it came after showing. As in

...showing practically that he is tough....

  • "its too far to walk" - it's – John Dvorak Dec 7 '16 at 23:39

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.