0

Which sentence is correct:

Mine are the red packages on the right
My are the red packages on the right.

Thank you very much for the help!

  • 1
    You need a pronoun (mine), not a determiner (my), so "mine" is correct. – Mick Dec 5 '16 at 18:05
  • Mine is a [pro]noun form, so you can say Mine is red just as you can say My car is red. But my is a "possessive determiner", similar to That car is red. Note that forms like Mine is red, This is red are only valid when the specific noun (car in my examples) is already contextually established, and in those cases you have to use mine, yours, hers, ours, theirs, not my, your, her, our, their (but his is the same in all contexts). – FumbleFingers Dec 5 '16 at 18:11
  • What is the context of saying this? – sumelic Dec 5 '16 at 19:42
1

Your first sentence using "mine" is the correct one.

Mine is a possessive pronoun, so you use it in place of a noun, e.g. "that's mine". My is a possessive adjective (also called a determiner); you use it to describe a noun as your own, e.g. "that's my umbrella".

1

*My are the red packages on the right.

This sentence is incorrect, so you definitely shouldn't use it. The word "my" can't stand by itself; it can only occur before another word in a noun phrase (such as "my things").

Mine are the red packages on the right.

This is grammatically correct, but to me it sounds odd. Normally, you use "mine" to describe things you own or have that you can identify from the context. A typical example might be to avoid repeating a previous noun, as in these two sentences:

His hands are warm. Mine are cold.

"Mine" stands for "my hands"; this allows the speaker to avoid repeating the word "hands".

But if you put "mine" at the start of an utterance, it's hard to see how a listener could infer what things of yours you're talking about. That makes your sentence seems strange to me. If you just want to say that you own the packages on the right, I think it sounds more natural to say

The red packages on the right are mine.

Again, I'm not saying the other word order is ungrammatical, just that it doesn't sound as good to me.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.