6

Can I say "something is happened to my phone"?

The word 'is' in the phrase is showing still the problem 'is' existing and affecting me not to use my phone, no calling. But since it happened before few hours, I want to express that by saying 'happened' which is past tense.

Please, I need help my English is low.

Does "something is happened to my phone" explain that the problem started some time ago and is still happening?

  • 1
    Welcome to ELL! I have edited your question to try to make it more clear. If what I added is not what you meant, you can edit your question or you can leave a comment with @ColleenV in it and I will try to help. – ColleenV parted ways Jan 9 '17 at 0:29
7

You can say "something happened to my phone". That tells your listener that the thing that happened, happened in the past. Your listener doesn't know whether there is still a problem. So you'd have to add more information: "something happened to my phone and now I can receive calls but not call anyone".

Or, "something has happened to my phone". Now we don't know how long ago it happened, but we're pretty sure that the problem still exists. "Something is wrong with..." means almost the same thing, but here we know for sure that the problem exists now. [You had the right idea. Your only problem was that it isn't good grammar to use "is" with "happened", though everyone would understand what you mean. To be grammatical, you have to use "has" for that construction.]

Or, "something is happening to my phone". With present-progressive, we know that the problem is in the process of changing the phone in some way. The phone might not be unserviceable yet, but whatever is happening will probably have an unwanted result.

  • Great answer though it may be slightly more helpful to explain why "is happened" is ungrammatical, i.e. clashing tenses. – Jake Jan 19 '17 at 16:41

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.