1

(a) If it began snowing, the coaches decided to cancel the game.

(b) Once it began snowing, the coaches decided to cancel the game.

Which one makes sense?

I usually use If to express a future situation. If the situation happens, it will bring the corresponding events.

I use simple present tense in the adverbial clause. As for the events, I use Will/Would to express the future tone explicitly.

According to the above description, I make some sentences.

(1) If it rains tomorrow, I will not go see a movie.

(2) If my brother passes that exam, we will give a party.

(3) If you could turn it down, I would appreciate it.

Back to my original question, I think it's perfect if I make one or two minor modifications.

If it begins snowing, the coaches will decide to cancel the game.

I'm not sure whether once has the similar usage of the tense.

I have no idea about the precise bearing of the original sentence. It uses the past tense! In what situations do such kind of past tense appear?

My question might be not loud and clear, but much appreciate if any one come up with good answers.

  • What do you think and why? – snailplane Oct 28 '13 at 3:45
  • 1
    Good question. The short answer is only (b) is acceptable (and I hope someone can explain why this is, because I can't! :) The curious thing is if we shift the tense so we're describing what the coaches would habitually do (XXXX it began snowing, the coaches would decide to cancel the game), you can use any of If, Once, When for the first word (they all have different implications for how often it would begin snowing during a game). – FumbleFingers Reinstate Monica Oct 28 '13 at 4:47
  • @snailboat: Thanks your reminder, I have rewritten my question. – eslsyc Oct 28 '13 at 11:28
1

The basic difference is if is a conditional, uncertain. Once is only pointing to a given moment of time, with no uncertainty whether the event happens or not.

They will attack at dawn. If we lose... No, not if. There's thirty of them against the three of us. Once we lose, don't surrender. You don't want to learn what they do to prisoners.

In your case, of the past sentences, once (b) makes much more sense: we already know it started snowing and the coaches canceled the game. You could transfer it into a conditional: we don't know what weather was at the game, so:

If it began snowing, the coaches would have decided to cancel the game.

In your question, the phrasing should make it clear, what the coaches will do:

If it begins snowing, the coaches will cancel the game.

If it begins snowing, the coaches will decide whether to cancel the game.

Now, the decision whether to use "if" or "once" depends whether you know it will be snowing or not. "Once" means you have a sure-fire weather forecast, you know that future event. "If" means an eventuality.

| improve this answer | |
  • Thank you very much. You give me an excellent example. The battle scenes and the vivid pictures are present to my mind. – eslsyc Oct 28 '13 at 15:49

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.