1

I'm aware than we can use so after some verbs instead of repeating an object clause, especially in short answers. The verbs we do this with most are: appear, assume, believe, expect, guess, etc. A typical sentence of this type would be:

-Are you having a party tomorrow?

-I guess so

My question is as follows: Can we use so in a similar way in a combination with other kinds of verbs? For example, with: plan, consider, etc? Like in the following example:

-Are you having a presentation on Friday?

-I`m planning so

OR

-Are you moving to NY next year?

-I'm considering so

1

[CONVENTION: In my answer when I say Verb Phrase or in short VP, I mean a verb attached with an auxiliary verb (if any) along with its complements and modifiers.]

The word - so - as used in your question is a Pro-form. A pro-form, as you must know, substitutes a string of words or a single word. Not only that it can even substitute a whole clause or a phrase.

Generally in Verb Phrase structure the Pro-form - so - substitutes complements. Various word categories can form a complement. It can be a phrase (a Noun Phrase, an Adjective Phrase, an Adverb Phrase, a Preposition phrase etc), a finite clause or even a non-finite clause.

We are planning to visit Goa next month. [Marked in italics the complement here is a non-finite clause, a to-infinitive clause introduced by the subordinator to.]

I expect that everything is going to be alright soon. [Marked in italics the complement here is a finite clause, introduced by a subordinator that.]

I like him and she likes the way I get attention from the crowd. [Marked in italics the complements here are Noun Phrases.]

Please don't treat [him] [badly]. [Marked in italics. Here there are two complements, marked by third brackets. One complement is a Noun Phrase and the other complement is an adverb.]

We remain hopeful of your success. [Marked in italics the complement here is an adjective phrase.]

The Pro-form - so - can substitute complements formed by most of clauses and phrases.

Were they sad to see you? I think so. [so here substitutes a finite clause, introduced by the subordinator - that they were sad to see me.]

A large percentage of school-age students were overweight, or at the risk of becoming so. [so here substitutes an Adjective Phrase headed by an adjective - overweight.]

The two had become friends, the closest of friends, and remained so. [so here substitutes a Noun Phrase - the closest of friends.]

I can't ride that thing. Oh come on! You can so. [Here so substitutes a Verb Phrase (VP) - ride that thing. Notice that in this VP that so substitutes the auxiliary verb is not included. I believe this kind of substitution that so offers here is only limited to Spoken English or in Fictions where real-life speech is imitated. This is very colloquial. You are not going to find any other auxiliary verb to work with so, the way can so is used.]

It, however, can't substitute complements formed by some clauses or phrases. For example generally it can't substitute a to-infinitive complement or a Gerund-Participle clause as complement, or an Adverb Phrase as complement.

Are you moving to NY next year?

I'm considering so [INCORRECT]

Verbs whose complements can be substituted by so are -

Think, Guess, die, Look, Feel, Become etc.

N.B - The verb - like - is not among the verbs whose complement can be substituted by so. Yet you probably can find similar sentences and they are correct -

Then you add your tomato, like so.

like so here is a set expression, meaning in this manner.


All the quoted sentences with so in your question are correct, except the one with consider so.

| improve this answer | |
  • 1
    I think you're on the right track; but I think you'll find that in this S-V-so construction so only refers to finite complements, not infinitivals, gerundials or participials. In effect, only verbs which take that clauses qualify, and not all of those: confirm, doubt, realise, resent don't--and neither does consider in the sense in which OP uses it. See CGEL, Ch.17,§7.7,1534-40. – StoneyB on hiatus Feb 5 '17 at 19:08
  • @StoneyB Thank you for the reference. Actually I was looking for some sort of reference from the very beginning. I will surely look into it and edit my answer. – Man_From_India Feb 6 '17 at 1:07
0

The answer is no: with consider and plan you cannot use so as you use it in: I guess so.

Please note: so here is the same as: I guess I will.

VERSUS: I'm planning to and I'm considering it.

This list of verbs takes so: appear, assume, believe, expect, guess,think,seem (partial list), look (one meaning of look)

These are not "action" verbs. They are verbs of expectation or belief.

Plan and consider are action verbs.

/So/ can stand for the auxiliary in many cases.

Do you think so? I think I do.

Did you or would you think so?- I thought I did or I thought I would

Have you thought so? I thought I have or had

Will you think so tomorrow? I think I will.

I will pass on providing any heavy grammar. That doesn't really help an ELL.

Whoops, I forgot the negative: I don't think so = I don't think I go. I didn't think so = I didn't think I did. It doesn't seem so =It doesn't seem it did.

| improve this answer | |

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.