1

George Hummel usually _____ with members of his department once a week to discuss schedule changes.

a) meeting b) meet c) meets d) have met

The answer is c, Ok,that's easy. But if I change 'have met' into 'has met', is this sentence correct, especially in grammar? So my question is;

George Hummel usually has met with members of his department once a week to discuss schedule changes.

Is this sentence correct? As a non-native, I'm often confused in using present perfect. So, Can I use present perfect with 'once a week'?

  • has usually met is much more natural than usually has met. – AmE speaker Feb 9 '17 at 12:55
1

Present perfect is permissible there, to describe a practice which has been in effect up to the present moment.

Reporter: Will Mr. Hummel continue to meet weekly with members of his department?
Press Liaison: Mr. Hummel has been meeting with them once a week, but going forward he may meet with them only once a month. How often they should meet in the future is the subject of today's meeting.

There, the present perfect continuous reinforces the idea of a situation which has been ongoing; the tense corroborates "once a week". But we could also say:

Mr. Hummel has met with them once a week...

to express much the same idea, the difference being that in the present perfect has met there is no sense of recurrence. The phrase once a week alone expresses that idea.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.