0

Is the following statement correct? should we add comma after bed?

The idea that she was still in the bed surprised me.

Can we move that-clause as following:

Surprised me the idea that she was still in bed.

Or Should we add it?

It surprised me the idea that she was still in bed.

  • There should not be a comma, because the sentence is fundamentally a simple subject-verb-object sentence: (The idea that she was still in the bed) (surprised) (me). So you wouldn't put a comma in there any more than you would put one in "The dog ate, the food." – stangdon Feb 25 '17 at 12:00
2

Surprised me the idea that she was still in bed.

This doesn't work because you have to have a subject before the verb.

It surprised me the idea that she was still in bed.

This is better, but it is a pronoun representing the idea. It is therefore unnecessary to repeat the idea.

It surprised me that she was still in bed.

If you want to get rid of the subject, you could use passive voice:

I was surprised that she was still in bed.

| improve this answer | |
1

The idea that she's still in bed surprised me.

"that she's still in bed" is a defining relative clause, so the sentence doesn't need commas before and after the clause.

As for the sentence "Surprised me the idea that she's still in bed", it's not grammatical as replied by @JavaLatte.

You can use 'it' to introduce the subject or object of a sentence, especially when the subject or object is a clause of the sentence as follows:

It surpised me that she's still in bed.

| improve this answer | |

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.