2

I found this sentence:

She asked if I'd had a good time on my holiday

I'm not sure if 'd is the short form of would or of had.

Is there any criteria (for an English language learner) to understand the correct meaning of 'd?

2

"I'd" is used an abbreviation for both "I had" and "I would".

Which it is short for can be inferred from context.

If it is followed by a past participle, it stands for "I had":

  • I'd seen him before
  • I'd gone to the shops.

Otherwise, it stands for "I would":

  • I'd rather go anywhere else
  • I'd see him quite often

So in your sentence "I'd" can't stand for "I would", because "would" always has the basic verb form (go, see, have etc.) after it. That means it definitely has to be short of "I had".

  • In this case, the contraction avoids the construction "had had" (past perfect marker + past participle of "have"). While this construction is perfectly legal, the contracted form is slightly easier for some native speakers to parse and is gaining currency relative to the uncontracted form. – Kevin Mar 4 '17 at 20:14

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.