3

What is difference between didn't have and hadn't? I have learnt to build questions in past simple with an auxiliary verb do. When can we use the second form?

Do these two sentences below have the same meaning?

I didn't have a car last Friday.

I hadn't a car last Friday.

Thanks for an explanation.

2

I didn't have a car last Friday

says roughly the same as

I hadn't a car last Friday.

The first statement represents the more usual construction today. Remove the negative:

I did have a car last Friday

and

I had a car last Friday

and the relationship between to two statements remains. The verb "to do" adds a little emphasis in the first statement, but does not alter the meaning.

The most common construction these days to express the negative in this statement without the verb "to do" would be:

I had no car last Friday.

  • Thanks @J.Taylor . Can we use the construction with did verb common? I mean e.g.: I did work in my lab yesterday. or I worked .... is still usual. – Ľubomír Masarovič Mar 1 '17 at 17:05
  • 1
    @Ľubomír Masarovič....The verb "to do" assisting another verb is most common as a negative... "I didn't work in my lab yesterday"; as a positive statement "I worked in my lab" , without "to do" is more common.. "I did work" is more emphatic than "I worked" ..."I did work" is used to leave no doubt that "I worked". Likewise, "I did have a car last Friday" leaves no doubt. that "I had a car". However, as a negative statement, "I didn't have a car" is much more common than "I had not a car". so, "I worked not" is uncommon use, but "I didn't work" is common usage. That is what it is today. – J. Taylor Mar 1 '17 at 19:01
3

Usually, do is omitted in English sentence except in question. It is possible to say I do have sth but this is shortened to I have. However in questions you must say Do I have? therefore because did or didn't is the form of do you can just use the second sentence I hadn't ... unless you are forced to use the first one.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.