1

Can Somebody explain me the difference between

Our return date will be depending on the cost of airline ticket.
Our return date will depend on the cost of airline ticket.

Somebody tried to explain it but it is not clear for me

both are in the future but with will be depending you have no idea when you will return that is the difference that I have understood . Am I wrong ?

  • Please refer to this link. Maybe it helps! – Mr. Xcoder Apr 21 '17 at 13:31
  • 1
    Idiomatically, future continuous will be depending on is completely unacceptable, but the explicit future will depend on is relatively unlikely for most speakers in most contexts. The idiomatic standard is Our return date depends on the cost of [an / our / the] airline ticket. Note that your lack of a "determiner" before airline ticket is also completely unacceptable. – FumbleFingers Reinstate Monica Apr 21 '17 at 14:10
1

I will start by saying there are several subtly different definitions of the verb depend, but for the purpose of this answer I will focus on two of them.

  1. (Actually two slightly different definitions, but sufficiently similar in usage for my purposes) to rely upon for support or maintenance; to rely/place trust.
  2. To be conditional or contingent on something.

Will be depending can only be used in the sense of definition 1, it is at the very least not idiomatic in the sense of definition 2, and may be grammatically incorrect (hopefully someone can point out a reliable resource that says whether it is "against the rules").

The best way I can think of explaining it, is as follows.

  • In definition 1, the state of something remains as it is, and relies upon something to keep it that way. Therefore the verb "be" is appropriate, because the state is dependent.
  • In definition 2, the state of something might change and the change will be contingent on something. Therefore, "be" is not appropriate, but "change" could be ("Our return date will change depending on the cost of airline tickets.") because the change (not the state) is dependent.

An example to attempt to explain the subtle difference:

I will be depending on the weather tomorrow. - I am relying on the weather doing what I want it to.

The kick-off time for tomorrow's match depends on the weather. - The kick-off time might change, and the condition determining the change is the state of the weather.

In your examples you are saying that the return dates are contingent upon the cost of the airline tickets, so you can't use "will be depending". As FumbleFingers said, you can use will depend, or more idiomatically depends. You can do this because the return date has not been decided, so, as well as being dependent in the future, it is also currently dependent upon finding out the costs.

Also, as FumbleFingers said, you need a determiner [an/the/our] before "airline ticket", unless you pluralise "ticket" to "tickets", when you don't need a determiner.

  • I will be depending on the weather implies that I have planned something before . If it rains tomorrow, I will watch the tv , if the weather is hot tomorrow, I will walk. So if it has been planned before can I also use present continuous ? Great explaination by the way – user5577 Apr 21 '17 at 16:38
  • @user5577 Use of "will be depending on" does not imply a change of action, more a reliance on something. E.g. You are going on a boat, but get seasick, you might be depending (rely) on the weather being nice so you are not (quite so) sick. That is different from saying "Whether I get the boat depends on the weather", which means that my decision on whether to get the boat is affected by the weather. – SteveES Apr 21 '17 at 16:48

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.