1

Do all of these make sense?

  • He was the only chosen person out of a hundred others.
  • He was the only chosen person of a hundred others.
  • He was the only chosen person among a hundred others.
  • He was the only chosen person in a hundred others.

It's just that I've seen all four in, among, out of and of used with choosing and selecting:

  • Two shots in ten tries hit the target.
  • The house was among the trees.
  • Only three of five songs were recorded today.
  • They were out of a bigger group of animals.

Are they all correct?

1

Of your sentences

He was the only chosen person out of a hundred others.

Your self-made sentences are not really analogous to your examples.

More similar examples might be

He was the only one out of a hundred others chosen.
He was the only chosen person from among a hundred others.
He was the only chosen person, one in a hundred.

0

You can choose something from a pool of options. Out of your self-written sentences, only the first one,

He was the only chosen person out of a hundred others,

is correct as it makes use of "out of", which is analogous to "from".

Even in the example sentences, you gave, only the last one,

They were out of a bigger group of animals,

which uses "out of", conveys the sense of a particular thing being chosen from a pool of options.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.