2

I have never seen" like " with present perfect why ?

Is it possible to say I have liked that book or should I say I liked that book for me these have different meaning first one I still like it and second it is the past it doesnot give any info we don't know if I like it

1

You would use present perfect like if you are saying you regularly or more than once liked something that happened in the past, and plan to do it again.

A: So I hear you like sherbet.

B: That's true.

A: Did you ever have the orange sherbet at Johnny's Icecream Shop?

B: I used to. All the time. I've liked that a lot. It's been awhile but I think I'm going to go tomorrow.

Non-perfect like will work too. But have liked won't work if there isn't or can't be a plan to do it again, such as below.

A: So I hear you like sherbet.

B: That's true.

A: Did you ever have the orange sherbet at Johnny's Icecream Shop? It's a shame the place burned down and no longer exists.

B: I used to. All the time. I liked that a lot. What a pity.

  • so if I use past simple that obligatory means that I don't like it now or it depends on the context In your example when B says "I liked it a lot " he still likes it – user5577 Jun 16 '17 at 16:32
  • @user5577 Yeh, Past Simple is mostly about the past. Of course one might say something like "I liked that car" and not mean that he doesn't like it now. Present Perfect with like simply shares past enjoynesses with the listener in the meaning of "tasted" or "tried" for instance. – SovereignSun Nov 1 '17 at 3:48
  • As a matter of fact if you wish to say that somebody liked something just now, in the present, or just merely before you said it, you can use the Past Simple. "Give the dog some sausage. - Here you are boy - Oh, look he liked that (the dog enjoyed the food just now)" However, I met that in several sources, last of which is the Fallout 4 game, it's still correct to use either the Past Simple or the Present Simple. – SovereignSun Nov 1 '17 at 3:55
0

It is uncommon to see the verb like used in the present perfect because it is not usually necessary, or its meaning could be ambiguous. If you currently like something then the simple present is used, and if you used to like something (but don't anymore) then the simple past can be used.

That doesn't mean that you can't use it with the present perfect (or any other perfect for that matter). For example, you can use it if you want to say how long you have liked something for (I have liked football for as long as I can remember), or in the subjunctive mood to say that you would have liked to have done something, had you been given the opportunity (I would have liked to have met Gandhi).

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.