5

Can I have it uploaded and I've uploaded it be interchangeable?

Is there any differences between them?

More question relating to I have it uploaded:

  • Is uploaded used as adjective?

When I'm writing on my own, this is so confusing.

Somebody can give me more examples to understand like I have it uploaded?

0
2

There are some contexts where I have it uploaded and I've uploaded it carry the same (relevant) information, so you could say they're "interchangeable" in those specific contexts. For example, suppose you're in a wi-fi cafe with a friend...

Do you want to listen to my new song? ...
1: I've uploaded it.
2: I have it uploaded.

(note that both alternatives above could reasonably be followed by something like ...into my public Dropbox folder, to which I emailed you a link this morning).

But in most contexts there would be at least a shade of difference in meaning (if the upload process was difficult/unusual, for example, the speaker might attempt to emphasise this by using the more "verby" construction #1). As OP suspects, uploaded in #2 is effectively an "adjectival" usage. Compare...

Do you want a beer? ...
3: I have some stored in the fridge. (past participle used adjectivally)
4: I have some cold in the fridge. (explicitly adjectival usage)

(where it's contextually unlikely the speaker means someone else stocks his fridge with cold beer!).


The construction TO HAVE [something] [X'ed - past participle] can also be used to mean to get someone else to X something for you (where context may imply either a "one-off" or habitual process; the syntax itself implies nothing on that front). But this is a declining usage - people increasingly say (He) gets his car serviced (by a local garage) rather than ...has his car serviced.

1
  • This is the best explanation ever! I've been confused about that usage in grammar. it's really helpful! Thank you very much for the excellent explanation. – Eunsim Kang Jul 10 '17 at 23:16

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.