6

Regarding participle adjectives (amazing, amazed, sending, sent..), when the verb is a phrasal verb (fill up/in/out), where should it be placed as an adjective?

The filled out form will be sent to the store.

The form filled out will be sent to the store.

I know that when the participle acts as a single adjective, without any modifier, it comes attributively (before the noun) - The amazing boy is here; however, when there are other modifiers, it comes as a post-modifier (after the noun): The boy amazing the girls is here.

So, since "out, up and in" in "fill" belong to the verb, should I treat it as an "additional information" and place it as a post-modifier, or treat them as elements that make up the verb and place them attributively?

Thank you.

  • "The boy amazing the girls is here" isn't something I normally hear. Where did you get the example? – user178049 Jul 8 '17 at 13:57
  • 1
    @user178049 I had the same gut reaction, but you can make yourself reparse it: The boy (who is) amazing the girls is here. It's become a participle instead of an adjective (and we have "the girls" because "amaze" is a transitive verb). Asker: From this we can naturally draw the conclusion that both are fine - we just have to realize that the internal structure of the sentence changes a lot more than it looks like. "The filled-out form" vs. "The form (you have) filled out." Note the hyphen. – Luke Sawczak Jul 8 '17 at 14:14
  • 1
    @LukeSawczak I see. I was confused because the OP said it has more than one modifiers. I see only one here, The boy [amazing the girls] is here. It's a good question, btw. – user178049 Jul 8 '17 at 14:21
  • Nice answers. @user17809 When I say "modifiers", it also includes "objects"; and Luke got it right, "amaze" is a transitive verb, but we normally don't hear such things as: I will amaze you; instead, we are more likely to hear: I will get you amazed. Which is also a participle that derives from that verb. – Davyd Jul 8 '17 at 16:48
  • 1
    @Prodigy Actually, "I will amaze you" would be better. Maybe "You will be amazed", though. – Luke Sawczak Jul 8 '17 at 16:51
1

Honestly, in formal writing, I would probably avoid either one of those. Possible alternatives include:

  • The completed form will be sent to the store.
  • Once the form has been filled out, it will be sent to the store.
  • The form will be sent to the store after being filled out.

But in everyday English, it's fine to use filled out as a premodifier. Personally, I would hyphenate it for clarity:

The filled-out form will be sent to the store.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.