7

What is the difference between the following sentences?

There was a woman in red earrings.

There was a woman with red earrings.

There was a woman with wearing red earrings.

I understand that "in" can use with clothes like "a man in the grey suit.", but I'm not sure I can use "in" with other things like earrings and necklaces, etc.

What is the difference between the highlighted sentences, and can I use in with items of jewelry such as earrings?

9

As a rule of thumb, I would use "in" for larger items of clothing that clearly contain significant parts of the body (shirt, pants; even hats, shoes, and gloves) and "with" for smaller accessories (including earrings and necklaces). "Wearing" can be used for both, but has a more formal/stuffy tone. "With wearing" is never correct -- use one or the other.

Of course there are many nuances; for example all of these are idiomatic:

There was a woman with a red dress (but see the comment below)

There was a woman wearing a red dress

There was a woman in a red dress

There was a woman wearing red

There was a woman in red

but have increasingly strong connotations about how distinctive the red dress was.

  • This is a good answer, and I've upvoted! :) But I would caution readers that your first example is a bit ambiguous. I would read "...with a red dress" to mean that the woman is holding a red dress, not wearing it. I suppose the interpretation of her wearing it is possible, but I don't think it is likely. I'd like this answer better if the first example were removed, because the rest are excellent! – WendiKidd Nov 30 '13 at 2:24

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.