1

Harry was almost glad that the exams weren't far away. All the studying he had to do kept his mind off his misery. He, Ron, and Hermione kept to themselves, working late into the night, trying to remember the ingredients in complicated potions, ....

-Harry potter and the sorcerer's stone (J.K Rowling)

"keep to themselves" mean 'to spend time alone, not talking to other people very much'. But I'm not sure if it means

(A) Harry, Ron, and Hermione each spent time alone. So even the three of them barely met each other?

(B) Harry, Ron, and Hermione spent time with each other only, not talking to other people?

If it means (A), and if I want to make a sentence which means (B), using 'keep to themselves', how should the sentence be?

  • 1
    I don't know the greater context, but "He, Ron, and Hermione kept to themselves" by itself could mean either A or B. But since all three were doing the same thing, my guess is that they were as a group staying away from others. – user3169 Jul 24 '17 at 18:05
1

To unambiguously express A, you could, as you suggested in your question, say "Harry, Ron, and Hermione each kept to themselves".

To express B, I would probably do as J.K. Rowling did.

So without more context I would guess B.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.