3

I believe that the advantages of buying a property greatly outweigh the short-term savings to be made by renting.

In above sentence what is the role of to be in ("to be made")? Can I write "that are made" instead.

I guess "to be made" is the short for "that are intended to be made" if this is correct is this structure a general structure and can be use in other similar situations?

0

I think "to be made" is infinitive modifying "savings", which is equal to "that are to be made". Although you could probably use "that are made" instead, the meaning would be slightly changed because infinitive "to be made" implies things would be done in the future. Sometimes, I would consider this kind of "to be" is short for "that is/are to be". like, this is the decision (that is) to be made.

  • What kind of infinitive is "to be made"? How does an infinitive imply things that are done in the future? – P. E. Dant Jul 30 '17 at 8:28
  • isn't an infinitive common to express the future? eg. "We want our students to enjoy the course." – dan Jul 30 '17 at 8:52
  • @P.E.Dant To- infinitivals may be deployed as adjectivals with future or deontic sense (deonitics are inherently futurive): 1) as a predicative complement with BE: I am to return by Friday ... 2) As a postposed modifier: a plan to be supported. – StoneyB Jul 30 '17 at 13:25
0

As @P.E.Dant suggests, to be is expressing futurity.

I believe that the advantages of buying a property greatly outweigh the short-term savings to be made by renting.

In this context, to be is used as a modal verb in the first person singular, and is replacing, "that would be", or, "that could be", or "that should be". Note that would, should, and could are also modal verbs.

Ex:

I believe that the advantages of buying a property greatly outweigh the short-term savings that could be made by renting.

Check out this link for more details & examples.

Lastly, its worth noting that to be is also conveying a degree of uncertainty, or opportunity. Its not necessarily guaranteed that savings will be made, just that they can be made.

  • I think you are misled by the heading at linguapress.com: in expressions like He is to be ... the 'modal' piece is not the infinitival complement to be but the form of BE which acts as the main verb--is in this example. CGEL Ch 3, §2.5.7, p. 113-4 calls this BE a 'quasi-modal': "in spite of its one modal property (and its modal meaning) this be doesn’t in fact qualify grammatically for inclusion in that class." – StoneyB Jul 30 '17 at 13:10
  • 1
    @StoneyB Heh! Leave it to H&P to state the thing with impenetrable squishiness. To be here acts like a modal on make, conveys futurity and supposition like a modal, but it isn't a modal? Verily, quasi forgiveth a multitude of sins. – P. E. Dant Jul 30 '17 at 16:55
  • I read the Linguapress piece early in the game but found, as @StoneyB points out, that this be is a different case. In those examples, some degree of obligation is conveyed, and the modality is in the am, is, and are forms (e.g.: "...savings he is to make") and not in the infinitive. Here, to be is also masquerading as part of a passive infinitive, which adds more confusion. – P. E. Dant Jul 30 '17 at 17:09
  • @P.E.Dant H&P follow the 'standard' use of the term modal verb, which is restricted to defective auxiliary verbs which must occupy the front position in verb constructions. It's an unfortunate term--there are lots of things (most of which aren't even verbs or verb constructions) which communicate modality--but H&P are pretty conservative about introducing new terminology. – StoneyB Jul 30 '17 at 17:10
0

It's simple.'To be made' means-something that should or needed to be done or made.On the other hand,'that are made' means-Something that's already made.Examples:'To be made'- There are some decisions to be made.So,this sentence means that there are some decision needed or should be made.'That are made'- Dishes 'that are made' by my mom are more delicious than hers.So, here it means that the dishes are already made and you are just commenting on her dishes.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.