0

Can I use the phrase 'having/taking a shower' as a noun when it supposed to be present simple tense

Example:

I wake up then (I) having a shower


Examples that I found:

1 use less water when washing their hands, brushing their teeth, or taking a shower

2 Finishing a good movie, and then having to face the reality of your boring life

3 Let’s go dancing at the club tonight

3.1 Swimming in the ocean has been Sharon’s passion since she was five years old

4 Wearing loose pants while riding a bicycle is dangerous

5 So more eating, more drinking and more taking of photos - many of them painfully embarrassing


Question:

Can I use the phrase 'having a shower' instead of have a shower in present simple cases (I wake up then (I) having a shower)?

  • Your I wake up then (I) having a shower is completely ungrammatical regardless of whether you repeat the subject I or not. In principle you could say things like He awoke having a headache or I awoke hearing the alarm clock (these are syntactically valid constructions). But in practice we'd more likely say He awoke with a headache or I awoke to the alarm clock. – FumbleFingers Aug 23 '17 at 15:43
  • Of your examples, the only one which is at all similar to the structure in the example is 2. And example 2 is not a complete sentence with a finite verb. It is just a noun phrase, understood to be a subject complement, the subject is implied by the question which is being answered.The twitter game is to suggest questions to which that could be the answer. – James K Aug 23 '17 at 19:10
4

No. Your underlying sentence I wake up and then I have a shower consists of two independent clauses. You may delete the repeated subject, but the second clause requires a finite verb.

Note also that I wake up and then I am having a shower is not acceptable either. Whether the simple present I wake up is deployed in a habitual sense ("On weekdays I wake up") or a narrative sense ("The alarm goes off. I wake up."), it is incompatible with a progressive continuation.

  • He can say, "I wake up, then after having a shower I brush my teeth." – SovereignSun Aug 23 '17 at 15:56
  • @SovereignSun- Could it also be "Then, having had a shower..."? But the context is: The first thing I do after I wake up is taking a shower. Why put all eggs in one basket where there is a definite sequence of habitual actions? I mean the sentence you are suggesting. Do you agree? – Lamplighter Aug 23 '17 at 16:20
  • 1
    @SovereignSun There, however, the shower is in a subordinate clause. – StoneyB Aug 23 '17 at 16:28
1

Can I use the phrase 'having/taking a shower' as a noun

Yes, mostly.

... when it supposed to be present simple tense

No. Gerunds cannot substitute for simple present tense. Note that {form of to be} + ing is a progressive or continuous verb form and not a gerund.

I wake up then (I) having a shower

Couple of problems here:

  • Gerunds don't take subjects. Simplifying things - they kinda-sorta can, but you use object or possessive pronouns instead of subject pronouns. E.g. *Me having a shower was refreshing or My having a shower worried her.

  • X then Y - then joins clauses, not nouns. So Y can't be noun or gerund, but Y can "recycle" head elements from X which can be elided. E.g. I woke up then showered = I woke up then I showered.

  • So something like I went walking then running will work because it's really I went walking then I went running.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.