I am confused with the usage of " or " . Here is two sentences that confused me;
i) He obviously doesn't have a plan, or he would have said something.
ii) He obviously doesn't have a plan, or would have said something.
I have taught that the second sentence is more advisable than the first sentence, yet grammar book which I studying from doesn't say so. Isn't the second "he" unnecessary? I don't know whether in English there is a incoherency due to using objects which are unnecessary.