0

Whose is that apple?

Whose appleis that?

Are both of these sentence structures correct? Can the word order be mingled with like this? There does not seem to be missing any clarity in either sentence.

I guess I would use such different word ordering to be able to but emphasis on certain words:

Whose is that apple?

Whose apple is that?

But is it allowed?

  • 1
    Both are correct. The former is preferred by some who prefer to (or erroneously believe they need to) not end a sentence with a dangling preposition. The latter is by far the more common way to ask this question in typical speech. – PMV Sep 9 '17 at 16:41
  • "That" is not a preposition, PMV; it is a demonstrative determinative – BillJ Sep 9 '17 at 18:07
2

Both are correct. In:

  • Whose is that apple?

"whose" is an interrogative pronoun and, syntactically speaking, the subject complement (SC). This can be demonstrated by the fact that the natural reply will be:

  • It (=That apple)'s mine. ("mine" is a possessive pronoun and the SC of the sentence).

Instead, in:

  • Whose apple is that?

"whose" is an interrogative determiner that accompanies "apple". The whole phrase, "whose apple", is the SC. Proof of this is that the natural reply will be:

  • It/That's my apple. (where "my" is a possessive determiner that modifies "apple", with the whole phrase, "my apple", being the SC of the sentence.)

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.