0

Why the word "both" is considered as a determiner (According to the Cambridge and the Collins dictionary)? Example sentence: Both kids walked a minute ago.

Isn't it a quantifier? Also if yes then could you please tell me how to know when a word acts like a quantifier and when it acts like a determiner?

  • 1
    Yes, but 'quantifier' is not a word category (part of speech) like 'determiner' -- it's just a subclass of the determiner category. Other subclasses of determiner include degree, sufficiency, paucal, existential, cardinal numbers, demonstratives, articles and a few others. "Both" can be a determiner in, e.g. "Both copies were destroyed" or a predeterminer (modifier) in e.g. "He ate both those burgers". – BillJ Oct 7 '17 at 18:37
1

Quantifiers are determiners (though not all determiners are quantifiers).

There are many different types of determiner. One way of classifying them is by position: there are predeterminers ("twice", "double", "half", "all", "both"); central determiners ("the", "a", "this", "my", "your"); and postdeterminers ("one", "two", "three", "several", "many", "few").

Most quantifiers are postdeterminers, i.e. they come after an article or possessive adjective (where present): "the many people", "his few friends".

"All" and "both" are predeterminers, i.e. they come before an article or possessive adjective (where present): "all the boys", "both his sisters".

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.