1

The problem with this neat triad is that, while a tirade against horoscopy might be perfectly agreeable to most everyone (being a machine gun attack on a whole field of straw men — who reads horoscopes save for feeble amusement?), assertions on life and climate are on another plane entirely.

Rex Murphy: Governor General appoints herself umpire of questions of faith and science

I googled and have understood the fallacy of a straw man, but still don't get the meaning of the bold phrase in the sentence above. What does it mean?

1 Answer 1

3

It's a metaphor. Attacks on "horoscopy" (by which I assume they mean astrology, but that's not important) are usually pointless since it's such an easy target to criticize, analogous to shooting down a field of stationary targets with a machine gun.

A common English idiom is "like shooting fish in a barrel", meaning something is ridiculously easy. The author tried to be clever by combining this metaphor with the "straw man" fallacy.

0

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .