0

Is "any" really necessary in the following sentences? If I omit in the sentences will that be grammatical?

Here are some examples:

1- When I reached John's home, I heard the barking of dogs. I asked john if there are (any) dogs in his house because I am scared of dogs.

2- Are there (any) ghosts in the world? What's your opinion, John? I don't believe there are (any) ghosts in the world.

3- Are there (any) humans who are immortal and can do anything they want.

3

Yes you can omit any in examples 1, 2 & 3, and the sentences are still correct, although personally I would keep any in the sentences.

I suppose any makes the sentence a little more specific, like:

Are there any ghosts (even one ghost) in the world?

or the difference between:

I want a girl to marry me some day.

versus

I want any girl to marry me any day.

Any makes me appear more desperate in this case. :)

I know you didn't ask this but in:

Can any native speaker please answer this question?

...any is not optional. :)

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.