In this sentence:

  1. I need a piano of my own on which to practice.
  2. I need a piano of my own to practice on it.

Which of the two answers is correct and why?

What if "of my own" is deleted?

What should I study so that I won't have such problems?

  • Sorry the form came out a little fuzzy . I need a piano of my own 1-on which to practice 2-to practice on it
    – Ali
    Dec 14 '17 at 11:01

Sentence one is correct.

In sentence two, "it" is something other than the piano and the piano is the thing that will be practised on "it". Consider this sentence:

I have a stage and now I need a piano to practise on it.

This means that you want to practise the piano on the stage.

If you omit the "it" in sentence two:

I need a piano of my own to practice on.

It become an acceptable - and more common - form of the sentence even though ending a sentence with a preposition is something up with which pedants will not put.

The "of my own" clause makes no difference to the sentence structure.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy