1

In this sentence:

  1. I need a piano of my own on which to practice.
  2. I need a piano of my own to practice on it.

Which of the two answers is correct and why?

What if "of my own" is deleted?

What should I study so that I won't have such problems?

1
  • Sorry the form came out a little fuzzy . I need a piano of my own 1-on which to practice 2-to practice on it
    – Ali
    Dec 14, 2017 at 11:01

1 Answer 1

3

Sentence one is correct.

In sentence two, "it" is something other than the piano and the piano is the thing that will be practised on "it". Consider this sentence:

I have a stage and now I need a piano to practise on it.

This means that you want to practise the piano on the stage.

If you omit the "it" in sentence two:

I need a piano of my own to practice on.

It become an acceptable - and more common - form of the sentence even though ending a sentence with a preposition is something up with which pedants will not put.

The "of my own" clause makes no difference to the sentence structure.

You must log in to answer this question.