1

Which tense would be appropriate for the below example,

20,000 dollars received as donation from January 2017 to till date

20,000 dollars has been received as donation from January 2017 to till date

The donation was received already and I'm going to report it to someone in a presentation. So I'm confused about whether I have to use simple past tense, because the donation was received and completed (or) I have to use present perfect tense because the donation was received however it is still related to the current moment because I've mentioned "to till date".

I'm confused because I have mentioned a time period from past to till date.

So please help me.

A simple explanation or answer is enough.

Thanks in advance.

3

"Received" is a transitive verb, so you need a subject and an object. You have no subject for the first sentence, so it's ungrammatical unless you make it passive:

$20K in donations were received from January 2017 until now.

The present perfect is also fine if and only if the date range is from some time until the current date:

$20K in donations have been received since January 2017.

  • Thanks for the answer. Can i use "until now" in your present perfect example (second one)? – Raj 33 Dec 17 '17 at 7:36
  • 1
    @Raj33 That's actually a more complicated question than you might think. "Until now" implies a change of some kind and so doesn't fit every context. "Until now, this factory has been producing shoes, but going forward we will also be producing hats." It doesn't make sense to use here unless there is a change in the amount of donations, and even then, it depends on what kind of change. – Andrew Dec 17 '17 at 18:59

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.