2

What is the meaning of this sentence:

"Any tiger is a dangerous animal."?

A. A tiger in general is a dangerous animal.
B. Any tiger, even a sick one, is dangerous.

12

Yes, you can, but in the context of your second sentence it makes more sense.

Two zoo workers are talking:

A. That old tiger can't be dangerous, it's hardly got any teeth left.
B. Look, any tiger is a dangerous animal. Always treat them with respect.

In a similar way, you can say

While most are not serious, emergency room workers treat any complaint of chest pain as if it might be a heart attack.

This baseball team is a mess. I think, at this point in our terrible season, any win is a major victory.

4

It could mean either one of your options, and perhaps it could be nuanced a couple other ways as well.

By the way, it's hard to take such a short English sentence and simply ask, "What does this mean?" Native speakers will invariably ask for more context.

I remember an exercise one time where a professor asked us to consider what went through our minds when we heard this sentence:

Mary had a little lamb.

For those who aren't' aware, Mary Had a Little Lamb is an old nursery rhyme and simple song that most people (at least in the US) are first exposed to at a rather early age. So, when we first hear that sentence, most people imagine something like this:

enter image description here

But the class was asked:

  • What if you knew that Mary was my girlfriend, and I had just told you that we went out to dinner last night?
  • Or what if Mary was the name of my sheep, and you knew she had been pregnant?

Suddenly, the pictures change quite a bit:
enter image description here enter image description here


In summary, the title of your question asks: Can I say, “Any tiger is a dangerous animal”?

My answer to that is: Absolutely. You can say anything you want. But that one is even grammatical.

You go on to ask: What does it mean?

My answer to that is: It means I'll be careful to avoid tigers – especially at night.

  • Re: "By the way, it's hard to take such a short English sentence and simply ask, 'What does this mean?' Native speakers will invariably ask for more context": Sadly, that's not true. Native speakers will often just assume a certain context (without even realizing that they're making an assumption). – ruakh Dec 29 '17 at 22:01
  • @ruakh - Perhaps so, but I was mostly talking about here on ELL. – J.R. Dec 29 '17 at 22:14
1

It can and does mean both. But it's a poorly constructed sentence.

To emphasize sentence A:

A tiger is always dangerous.

Here the emphasis is on the verb to be, it implies that whatever state a tiger is in, it is dangerous.

To emphasize sentence B:

Tigers are dangerous animals.

Here the emphasis is on what sort of animal tigers are, i.e., dangerous.

  • I like what you're saying here. But there are a few contexts where the OP's sentence might be quite appropriate (like the sample zookeeper dialogue in @Andrew's answer). – J.R. Dec 29 '17 at 21:59

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.