1
  • I found 100$ floating in the water

Why is “in” placed instead of “on” the water.

I thing they are on the surface of the water not in.

What do you think? money floating in the water

2

I think they are on the surface of the water, not in.

You are incorrect; the bills are both.

The phrase in the water is idiomatic. If we don't want children to swim, we might say, "Don't go in the water." Even though algae usually floats at the surface, you can see from this ngram that most writers prefer to talk about algae in the water, as opposed to algae on the water.

There would be absolutely nothing wrong with saying the money is on the water; the phrase on the water means "on the surface of the water," and clearly the bills in the image are floating.

However, your thinking veered into the wrong when you presumed that in the water was incorrect; in fact, "in the water" can mean anywhere in the water – submerged, floating, or a mixture of both.

0

on would certainly the right word for most of the notes in the picture because they are on the surface. There are several that are below the surface, though, and in the water would be a better word to use.

floating in water does occur, but there are certainly many more occurrences of floating in space than floating in water/the sea/a river. This is because space does not have a surface to float on.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.