1

I always appreciate all the people here. Today I have a question about will-would usage. I know there're lots of answers for them already. However I just need to learn them with my sentences for better understanding.

< Will >

A : You'll die for them?

B : Yes, I will!


< Would >

A : You'd die for them?

B : Yes, I would!

Those are movie quotes. I re-wrote them with help of dictionaries, which are below.

< Will >

A : Do you plan to save them, even though you know you can't survive while doing that?

B : I do and I promise.


< Would >

A : Do you REALLY want to risk your life for them? You could be killed!

B : I do and I hope so.

So, how close am I?

  • 1
    You're subtly shifting the context by moving from even though you know [you'll die] (the "saviour's" death is a certainty) to You could be killed! (possibly, but it's not a certainty). But in neither case does it make sense for the saviour to say and I hope so (unless he actually has a death-wish, which is a bit too weird to use in an example context here). – FumbleFingers Reinstate Monica Jan 25 '18 at 18:51
2

You're close. First, minor correction: "Will" is always future. Of course, it doesn't mean it will necessarily happen, only that it is expected to happen.

A : You'll die for them?

B : Yes, I will!

A: You intend to die for them?

B. Yes, I intend to die for them (hopefully not in vain).

A : You'd die for them?

B : Yes, I would!

A: Should the possibility arise, would you die for them?

B: Yes, should the possibility arise, I would.

Using will implies it is a question of time, not if. Using would means it is a conditional situation, and that it is not necessarily going to be the case.

Putting it in another context:

A: You'll do your chores?

B: Yes, I will!

A: You intend to do your chores?

B: Yes, I intend to do my chores.

A: You would do your chores?

B: Yes, I would!

A: Should I ask you to do your chores, would you do them?

B: Yes, should you ask me to do my chores, I would do them.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.